Reviews for Sal's Pizzeria in Ithaca, NY
Wow. I feel at a lost that I did know Sal's pizzeria did not existed here in Ithaca NY. I spoke with a man who had been... frequenting Sal's for over thirty years. Thirty years! And he describes it as " classic and convenient." He further stated thatSal's is the best pizzeria he knows. I on my first time visit must agree. So if you happen to drive by Agway and look to yourright Sal's stands right tall next to Stafkings and the Vape Shop. Stop in and try the best pizza and wings in all of Ithaca. Read more
Amazing people, always so friendly every time you walk in and the food is always delicious no matter what you end up getting.... There's enough on the menu to keep you coming back and finding a favorite Read more
Was in Ithaca for a family event, went searching for palatable pizza and on the 5th try, found Sal's. GREAT place! Tried a... couple of slices and they were better than 99.9 percent of CT pizza and would hold their own in the Bronx. Circled around afterwife also approved the pizza and got a chresesteak w/mushrooms and onions and a meatball parm. Meant to try a couple of bitesof the cheesesteak to avoid spoiling my appetite for the family event but OMG ate half of it, just perfect everything onit...good meat, onions cooked down, and mushrooms. Great owner amd crew in a desolate, non-high profile outpost...great,reasonably priced food. If we lived anywhere near Ithaca we'd be eating there twice a week. Try 'em! Read more
We went following a hike to nearby taughannock falls. The pizza was authentic new york style pizza. Delicious...we enjoyed it
Best pizza in town. Wonder staff, love them ??
Wow!!! What a great find!! Just received delivery of boneless wings with garbage can sauce, tastes home made, tossed salad, ... which was actually Fresh, ( too often is prepackaged) garlic cheese bread was amazing , 1 large 1/2 cheese 1/2 pepperoni, great crust, sauce and fresh cheese. Delivered to slip at Marina, delivery person was polite and friendly. Read more
Got to go pizza. Solids pie. Crust cooked great a long with a great tasting sauce. Great service.
Foods always good. Great staff. Clean