Reviews for Pete’s Pitaria and Other Fine Foods in Island Park, NY

Their Gyro platter is unbelievable, the hummus is the best homemade I?ve tasted and you cannot pass on the spicy feta, that?s a... must! Read more

I get fuel prices being extremely high food shortages ??BUT a gyro dinner, grape leaves and a order of lemon potatoes ( looks... like side order) I did use Uber eats there fee was $8.50 Even with that fee there is no way my total was $51.00 sad part is Ienjoyed there food for years until today Read more

Always banging and fresh!!!! Try the bbq marinated lamb gyro. The best in north east America

Best greek around. Portions are huge. Favorite is a greek salad with gyro meat, humus and yogurt sauce with pitas on the side to... split with another person. Super friendly and always busy. Read more

Great food! Excellent Greek Salad and Fries. Chicken was a bit dry but can?t wait to try more of their menu!

Best Greek food around the gyro meat is amazing and the hummus is rich and creamy and loaded with flavor the tahini is... fantastic the pitas are fresh and the spinach pie is great Read more

Good quality Greek/Lebanese style food. Owner came over to see how we were doing. They accommodated our large party even... though it was near closing time. Read more

The food is good, but the staff has often made inappropriate/judgey comments about what I am ordering. When I order take out... from them, I usually buy enough food for two meals for two people. On FIVE separate occasions, either the owner, or an employeehas remarked ?wow that is a lot of food.? These comments have made me feel incredibly uncomfortable, and almost want to cancelthe entire order. If it happens again, I do not plan on ordering from them EVER AGAIN. This is the only restaurant that evermakes a comment about the quantity of food I buy. Read more