Reviews for Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet in Islamorada, FL
OMG!!! All you can eat seafood!! Everything was delicious. We stuffed ourselves and had to be rolled out! The service was... excellent, staff was very nice and friendly. There is a boat dock but limited space. Read more
Great service from Edwin, but the food was completely underwhelming. We visited on a Thursday night, and the restaurant only had... about twenty people seated. (The dining area could easily seat 200 people.) Perhaps because they were only at ten percentcapacity, the buffet was barely filled. The food quality was mediocre - certainly not worth the price of $40 per person.Couldn't eat the mashed potatoes because they were sweet?!? When the restaurant is full, perhaps on a weekend, they probablyhave more, higher quality, food available. Based on this experience, however, we would not return. Read more
The food was amazing. I don?t know why so many people say that this restaurant is bad. Sure it is expensive but I think that it... is worth it. The pasta was good but we got bored of it after eating half a plate. Dessert was good too . Overall this restaurantis good and my friend liked it. Read more
Food was pretty good, views were good. The whole place was nice and clean. Our server wasn't too nice though. Multiple tables... by the windows were open and they acted like they didn't want to sit anyone at them. I would've gave them 5 stars had lobstertails and snow crab been on the buffet. But you have to pay extra for those. Ate at another seafood buffet 2 days prior inOrlando and they had all you can eat lobster tail and snow crab in their buffet as well as the other seafood. I guess it'sbased on location? ??????? Read more
Awesome experience from start to finish, the food was tasty and the staff were friendly our waitress Suanne was really good and... I believe she needs promotion probably one of the best I?ve ever had. I would definitely recommend visiting here Read more
Must visit! This was absolutely the best seafood buffet ever! I left so full of local fresh seafood from fried, grilled,... charred, blackened, raw, they have it all! Read more
We have not been back in 4 years, the place didn?t disappoint. They have a lot of diversity, soups, paella, salmon, prime rib,... tacos, rice, beans, amarillitos, fried fish, fried shrimp, fish piccata, clams, mussels, seafood stuffed creps, a pasta station,an amazing seafood station with blue crab, shrimp, oysters, calamari salad, octopus salad, shrimp salad, potato salad, desertsand ice cream. I am sure that I forgot some items. Our waitress Tamara was awesome?. A must do when at the Florida Keys Read more
We celebrated my father's 80th birthday here and we all had a fantastic time! The food was good, there were different favorites... amongst everyone including the octopus salad, fried shrimp, chicharron, crabs and the tres leches and flan from the desserts.The view is gorgeous! Even seating afar from the windows, and the service! The service deserves 10 stars out of 5. Everyone wasalways so helpful with the best attitude since I first called and emailed weeks and days in advance. Ray, Robert, thank you forhelping me coordinate this very meaningful event. Edwin, our server, thank you for your smile, hard work and willingness to goalong with my ideas and very age-diversed party :) The rooftop bar with live music was the perfect after party! We all lookforward to being back here! Read more