Reviews for The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar- Pendleton Pike in Indianapolis, IN

I have to break this review into two parts. The good: service was good, the food came out quickly (the fried shrimp was great)... and the beverages were fresh and refilled without a wait. The not so good: the clams in the shells were virtually non-existent.The juicy sauce left much to be desired. In my opinion, you simply don't get enough food for your money. Great customer service! Read more

To be fair, we visited on a weekday afternoon. There were only two tables occupied. This made for an excellent atmosphere and... fanatic service! The food at Juicy is always great! This was my first time trying the catfish, as I've previously had theFirebird. It was delicious! Their juicy seafood sauce is the best! Read more

Apparently there were not enough servers. So we had to wait 15 minutes. When we were seated there was only 1 other person... sitting in the east side of the restaurant. The waitress came really quick to take our drink orders and food order. As the nightwent on, it got busier and she got less attentive and our drinks sat empty. We ordered the Fire Bird for 2. It food was fresh(didn't smell like the sea), hot and delicious. As long as the food remains good, we'll continue to eat here. Read more

The ambiance was appropriate for celebrations. This is not to be compared to Red Lobster. As my son said we wouldn't go there... after having a good grade on a paper. Worth every penny although.. it was mildly expensive. Read more

Would've only given this 2 stars but the server-Jaiya was def 5 stars...a genuine sweetheart that took great care of us. She was... upbeat, energetic & outgoing with a lovely smile. The seafood was not great--fried oysters were very tiny. Calamari andhushpuppies were good. It was basically fast food seafood quality. I'd go back for server/service we had but not food. Read more

We had a group of about 15 people for reservations at 8 on 5/21. Our server handled it so graciously (I wish I remembered her... name) she was always smiling, polite, and regular checked up on us. As for the food I was impressed I got the Mr. Captain mildCajun and it was amazing. My daughter got the chicken tender basket it was HUGE. If you order this for your child I wouldsuggest you have them share it! I also got the honey lemon mojitos which is a virgin drink and I loved it! For a seafood boilplace the pricing was reasonable. I noticed that it didn?t smell fishy at all which is a good sign of cleanliness. Read more

Had such a great time. My boo is allergic to sea food but he risked it all to make me happy. He had a great time and ate well.... Our waiter Andrew took great care of us. The manager didnt get her name but she had an ankle brace on. She had the best musicplaying. Made me want to start a soul train line in that place. We will definitely be back. I left juicified to the max and hadthe juicy wabble from the itis????. ???????????? Read more

The food was excellent! The service was good too. I actually went in for the fried oysters and at first tge waitress told me... they were out but after checking she informed me they had just received a shipment in today. They were cooked to perfection aswas the whiting we ordered as well. Try the cajun fries they wont disappoint!! All in all a very pleasant dining experience.Update: called ahead tonight to check on availability of oysters. None available. ???? Read more