Reviews for The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers in Indianapolis, IN

Came here to shoot some laid back maternity pictures because it's just so cute and who can beat a tea date with a friend! Carrot... cake and carmel apple macaroons were amazing! So was the fruit infusion tea! Can't wait to bring my 3 year old daughter here,she'll love it! Read more

Beautiful restaurant. Impeccable service. Beautiful presentation. The cake was undeniably scrumptious. Macarons were SO... delicious. The earl grey tea made me warm to my bones. I ordered the tomato bisque as well for my lunch and it was the onlything I thought “I’ve had better”. My friend very much enjoyed her lunch order though. I took home extra cake for thefamily. Enjoyed our day. Read more

My wife and I purchased 4 cakes from here for our wedding ceremony. These cakes were amazing and the best I have ever tasted.... It’s hard to pick a favorite but I think the Millionaire cake was the best. When we went to pick them up we ran late and theyworked with us on a later time. The shop was so busy and very quaint. Loved the atmosphere and plan on going back again forfuture occasions. 6 stars!! Read more

The cake bake shop is like entering a fairy tale; the decor is colorful, magical, sparkly, and perfect. My favorite items on the... menu are the broccoli quiche, Gwendolyn's famous earl's court chocolate cake, and the lavender lemonade. They put edible glitteron almost everything!!! I would give the quality of the restaurant food and service four stars because the food appearance,texture, and flavor are overall very consistent. Still, i have noticed that the service is not as attentive and quick to servecustomers. I was only disappointed once by the food because when i got my cake, it was cold, and I don't particularly enjoyeating it cold. Read more

This is an experience! I attended a birthday party in the restaurant. The decor made me wish I still had a little girl to treat.... The food is tasty. I had a rocket salad with toasted goat cheese and an appealing lemony vinegrette; my mother raved about butthe quiche. But the desserts are the star attraction. Spectacular. Special mention to the experienced, professional staff. Yougave my aunt a special day. Read more

The Cake bake Shop has the most beautiful ambience. We tried the Caprese Sandwich that comes with Freshly sliced tomatoes,... homemade pesto with walnuts, basil & mozzarella on a toasted baguette.For Dessert we had the Millionaire, Raspberry Champagneand Red Velvet Cake. If you have a sweet tooth then Cake Bake Shop is a must visit. Read more

This was my first time visiting the Indy location. I've been to the Carmel location previously. We were at the Indy shop... celebrating a friend's baby shower. Parking is somewhat hard to find. However, we were seated promptly and our waiter wasphenomenal and very accommodating. The decor is beautiful. It looked like an enchanted cottage. The food and drinks weredelicious, but expensive, which I expected. I had chicken velvet soup, a turkey sandwich, Neapolitan cake and the elderberrysparkler drink. The cake was well presented and moist. The icing was fluffy and flavorful. My only true complaint was there wasa squashed raspberry on the floor and stuck underneath our table that had not been cleaned up from previous guests. That wasgross and sticky when the mom-to-be in our party stepped in it and inadvertently got it on her dress when she sat down. Otherthan that, it was a wonderful evening and a pleasant experience. Read more

I loved loved loved the atmosphere of this shop. The teas were wonderful. My only issue was that we were under the impression we... were reserved until 2pm, but later told it was 130. But we ended up having to clear out at 1pm for the next party. I am a littlesad about that. Either way, I'll be back for my birthday! Read more