Reviews for Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern in Indianapolis, IN

Great place to eat and hang out. Food was perfect, service was spot on. We were in town for 2 nights due to family in the... hospital, and we did dinner here both nights. Read more

Had dinner here with my son 21AUG22. I had the breaded pork tenderloin and he had the cheese burger. This has to be one of the... best BPTs I've had. Not too thick not too thin, tasty breading, juicy. Just delicious?? My son reports that the burger was oneof the best he's ever had too. Great place, I'll definitely be back next time I'm in the Indy the area. Read more

Service was great. The inside design is pretty decent. Food was underwhelming flavor-wise but the portions for the price were a... great ratio. Read more

Happy hour is from 3-6 with half priced apps and pizzas, plus a $5 burger. They have daily specials on drinks as well! I got the... mushroom pizza, my husband got the $5 juicy Lucy burger, my mother in law got the tomato basil soup, and my toddler got the Macand cheese with fruit. We also got drinks- the draft margarita, draft rum punch, and red sangria and they were OK. A bit on thepricy side though for drinks. Read more

One server plus he was the bartender, but he was on it! Drinks were delicious and so was the food. Pork tenderloin tasted like... it fresh and not frozen. I definitely will be back! Read more

The food was so good. If you’re looking good good food, a nice atmosphere and good service this is the place to go.

Felt right at home as soon as I walked in. Bellied up to bar cause we were just having a cocktail and the 'famous' fried pickles... Google raved about. First the pickles: thick spear with great crunchy breading serves with ranch. Not very 'dilly', but not adeal breaker. Our bartender Catherine extended her hand, announced her name, smiled and it was game on. Honestly, she gets awardfor friendliest person in Indiana! She informed us of Happy Hour specials, gave us her favorites, just plan awesomeness! A greatfind. Read more

Atmosphere is nice. Regular sports bar feel. Waitress was very nice. Let’s talk about this fish and chips that I was... suggested… Two pieces of freezer to fryer fish. Definitely not fresh.. over cooked. Fries hot cold and warm… a mix offlavors.. bottom line, not even close to worth $15.99… I’m just saying. I could have went to Buffalo Wild Wings if I wantedpoor quality food. This will be my last visit. No thanks. Read more