Reviews for Red Key Tavern in Indianapolis, IN
I have always loved this bar. Plus it has the best burger in the city
My god, the cheeseburger?go?get it now. Best cheap burger you?ll ever have. No tap, but they have a decent selection of canned... and bottled beer. Try it out. Read more
Awesome place. We are here every year for the fair, and we stay two houses away. The burgers are simple but amazing. Great,... friendly staff! Read more
Excellent staff. Family owned. Historic. Best Cheeseburger in town. Chili is amazing (seasonal).
Wonderful place. Feel like I was in a 80?s movie scene. Have to try their cheese burger. Very tasty! Love that they have many... rules. One thing is they only accept cash. Read more
Red Key is a dinky little bar, but a good little bar. They have good drink specials throughout the week ($5 beer buckets on... Thursdays, I think?) and they've got consistently tasty burgers and potato salad! There are a few food items on the menu I'venever been able to try, because they always seem to be out of those things - but that's really my only complaint. If you'relooking for a super relaxed time and a genuinely good hamburger, this might be the place for you. Read more
This is what you'd call a dive bar. Set your expectations low so you're not disappointed too much. If you're looking for beers... and a good burger in a casual setting, then this might be a good place for you. It's not a good place to get cocktails --selection is extremely limited to just the basics and the basics are nothing to write home about. Had some Manhattans and theywere somewhat small portion in a Nick and Nora glass and we're just alright. Vodka martini was too much vermouth. That said, theburgers were really good. So beer and burger is probably the way to go here. One important note: this is a cash only place,which really amps up the dive feel. Seriously, 2022. I'll pay the CC fee. Better than the ATM at the back of the place. So thatthrows red flags like they must be evading tax or something, which is a turn off for me. Read more
Great burgers and potato salsa. They have been doing it for a long time.