Reviews for Pier 48 Fish House and Oyster Bar in Indianapolis, IN

Posted my birthday/retirement party at this restaurant. We compared them to three other places and for what we got and the price... for the sevice they are by far the best choice. We rented a private room and was able to decorate it and it accommodated 34guests! We had a buffet with two appetizers , three main courses, two sides and two desserts. Everyone that was at the partysaid they really enjoyed the food and the atmosphere. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. No regrets picking thisplace for our celebration event! Read more

Good choice downtown for seafood for sure. The food is somewhat hit or miss though. I’d say more hit than miss though. The... Scallop Dish is probably my favorite, Lobster Nachos are solid, and the truffle fries are excellent. The Filet was pretty goodfor Seafood Joint. I’d stay away from sandwiches and fried fish, crab cakes weren’t great either. Based on the food I’dgive this place a four, however the service was not great, drinks on the menu that aren’t available, entrees didn’t come outat the same time. It was definitely the service that made this a 3/5 for me, not the food. Really nice bar area too. Read more

Celebrating my friend’s birthday……our server was really nice and attentive. The appetizer were delicious. Three of us... ordered the catch of the day. It was a little over seasoned. The bourbon salmon was great. Overall, I will be returning in thefuture as I saw a few other items I would like to try. Read more

We came during lunch hours on Sundays the atmosphere was quiet and relaxing. We were the only people sitting outside. The food... was amazing. Megan is a server. My son enjoyed her as he gave her googly eyes and rubbed on her arm (he's only 8). Read more

Easy to make online reservation. Terrific service. Drinks and food were wonderful. Best seafood we've had in Indy and we've... tried many. Hubby got chargrilled oysters for a starter. So flavorful. Absolute perfection. I had the lobster grilled cheese. The bread was terrific, seasonings mild but complimented the lobster. Lobster itself was cooked just right and there wasplenty of it. Hubby chose the monkfish. It was tender and flavorful with a yummy sauce and nice presentation. Side of coleslawwas oversized and got the seal of approval for flavor. Pineapple margarita was refreshing and delicious. White chocolatemartini got high marks too. Everything we saw coming out of the bar and kitchen looked fabulous. Manager stopped by our tableto make sure all was well. You'll be glad you checked out this spot! Read more

Hit this seafood spot during our first time in Indianapolis. Oyster was delicious and the lobster roll tasted just fine. Service... was a little slow but overall, a good experience. Read more

Great experience, delicious food. Make reservations. We had a the Egg Roll Bowl and the Spicy Chicken Sandwich. Both were... excellent. Food quality and flavor were 5/5, and we were seated near the kitchen and everything coming out looked delicious.Staff was great as well. Can't wait to come back! Read more

It was my first visit. I had the fish/chips and wings. The fish was divine!! Seasoned perfection, light, and fluffy. French... fries were good. I was pleasantly surprised with the ketchup. It had a nice tangy taste. The cole slaw was the best I ever had.I could have ate another. The wings were smoky, juicy, and flavorful. A nice restaurant. I will be back. Read more