Reviews for Penn Station East Coast Subs in Indianapolis, IN

I really liked the food. The only thing that put a damper in the excellent experience it could've had was that the language the... crew we using wasn't suited for customers to hear. Otherwise, they did their job but didn't leave an impression if it wasn't forthe food. I'll try again and see if that's changed. Read more

Easy on the seasonings. Way too much oregano on the grill classic Italian and way too much salt on the grilled chicken teriyaki.... So much seasoning that we will not be eating here ever again. We got 2 large of each subs so almost $60.00 for ruined subs Read more

I live Penn Stotions food but this trip the service wasn't great. They need to repeat your order to you so you aren't missing... anything (which we were) and when we told the lady who brought our food she walked away without acknowledging she heard us untilI said it the 3rd time. Also I HATE booths so you either have to sit squeezed in a booth or sit on a high stool at a bar stylelong table. Read more

I swear this is my favorite sandwich shop anywhere. You simply must try their grilled Italian. They're fresh lemonade is pretty... good. If you want dessert, their cookies are soft and chewy (as I like them). Read more

It was good but when I tell you my sandwich had 1 Itty bitty piece of onion and one little piece of mushroom no banana peppers,... I'm not lying. I paid for a sandwich with all of the above. Read more

Tasty cheesesteak. Too much salt on the fries, but fries are good. Clogged toilet.

I heard great things about this place, especially their Philly cheese steak, which is what I got. I got mine with extra meat and... cheese and all the toppings. I've had many cheese steaks, and this one did not make it to the top of the list. It was ok, thesandwich wasn't juicy, the meat was dry, and you couldn't even taste the peppers. $19 for this sandwich and I have to say it wasa bust, and $3.70 for a "large" drink that's basically a medium at McDonald's. Like I said the food was ok, but the experienceand price wasn't. This for me, was a one time visit Worth 2 1/2 stars. Read more

Tea tasted weird. Girl said, "well I made it this morning." Proper response would have been, "I'm sorry, I will check it. Thank... you for letting me know." Another customer told me I picked the worst Penn Station and that the others were much better. I feltportions were a little small for the price, especially compared to Portillo's. Flavor was good, service was a bit not friendly.They could use a little training on customer service. Bathrooms were just ok. Fries were excellent. Read more