Reviews for Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub in Indianapolis, IN
I was a little annoyed and skeptical when we walked in. We had a hard time finding the place and circled the block before we... found it. The place wasn't trendy or fancy. It's a place where you are greeted by "seat yourself" sign. The pizza is amazing andquickly pushed away any reservations I had. The great selection of drinks on tap, including hard cider which was great. Myhusband agreed that this was in the top 5 of all of our pizzas. Read more
Great pizza. The BBQ chicken pizza ???? has just the right amount of sauce. Not too sweet, not too spicy. The meat lovers pizza... ???? is made with quality meat. The sauce is very good. The crust on the hand tossed was crisp throughout. Good draft beerselection too. Read more
I went here the other day with my boyfriend for the first time. I ordered the Bad Decision cocktail, which ended up being the... right decision lol. We ordered the cheesy breadsticks for the appetizer. They were HUGE! They were tasty and had the perfectlittle crunch every time you bit into it. They practically filled us up. I then ordered a Pearl Street calzone with pineappleand bacon. He ordered a supreme pizza. Everything was delicious! I would also like to mention that they weren't all that busywhen we visited. However, to me, that confirms that this place is just another hidden gem that no a lot of people know about.That also makes it a good place for group hangouts, because of all the extra seating. Also, shout out to Curtis ourbartender/waiter. He was cool. Read more
The last time I ate here I ordered the lasagna and it was the greatest and yummiest lasagna I have ever had. I'm sure everything... else is also delicious, but please try the lasagna if you eat here!!! Large portion, beef was so flavorful, the sauce wasAMAZING. I would eat it weekly if I lived in Indy! Read more
Had the pear & gorgonzola pizza and it was absolutely amazing! Super delicious with the perfect balance of flavors on a tasty... crust that didn’t overwhelm the toppings. Read more
The pizza is great and they have a lot of unique toppings. My friends got their pan pizza which is pretty thick/hearty. I got... the Mexican cauliflower crust pizza. The chorizo was so good and the crust was crisp. Read more
I left a 3-star review for Pearl Street Pizzeria not too long ago. I felt service was inattentive and lacking timeliness... exceeded boundaries of a lunch hour. As a local guide, I felt obligated to try again in fairness to a business that’s beenaround for years. We had the same server; this visit, I noticed no lag in table work such as drink refill struggles, mistakes,or delayed food delivery. The server was pleasant last time, but more energized on this visit. That energy translated a lessthan 40-minute in/out. The server also wrote our order instead of attempting memorization - a noted change that ensuredtransactions. Compliments to the team for rectifying our experience. Good Flavor remained consistent as with all my previousmeals. I now feel better moving forward with another lunch here. I added a photo of my order: Hand tossed 8” Meat Loverswith additional fresh Basil, Asiago, portobello, and cost receipt. Read more
Wow! I forgot how good this pizza was (Covid ????) and will be adding it back to the downtown rotation. Crust is the perfect mix... of garlic/butter/crunch/softness. Sauce to toppings ratio is perfection. Highly recommend the spicy Hawaiian. Forgot to take picof the food but here is the alley it’s in… Read more