Reviews for Hoagies and Hops Butler-Tarkington in Indianapolis, IN

What a gem! My husband and I got diverted in traffic, and landed at Hoagies and Hops. What a great discovery. Connected to... Chilly Water Brewing Co., you get the best of both worlds. Stellar cheese steak and pop next door for a great brew! Service wasgreat, food outstanding, and the brew was perfect. Now that we know where it is, we plan to stop by often. Read more

If you're tired of being bald, come to us. If you love delicious sandwiches and cold breskies, come to Hoagies and Hops! Great... experience, highly recommend. 10/10 ???? Read more

Fantastic experience at Hoagies & Hops. Kristina the owner recommended a couple of menu items, and if she says it's good...IT IS... GOOD! Everything about this Philly screams east coast. Delicious, perfectly cooked and tender meat, on an authentic hoagie roll.Not just the Philly, everything was fresh and phenomenal. 11/10 would definitely recommend. Read more

Boy did the Internet do a good job of tricking me. Photos all look amazing, I mean absolutely delicious. I made up my mind,... we're going to try Hoagies and Hops TODAY! Made the 40 drive, with my family, plenty of people sitting outside eating, otherspouring out the door upon our arrival, good sign? Should have been. Fast-forward to ordering. The idea was that my daughter andI were going to share a Philly but after seeing the small and regular bread on display, I wasn't sure sure regular was going tocut it but I also know $24 for a whole wasn't an option, sheesh. We ordered Philly Hoagie and the Hog Island Italian but regularin size with an order of cheese fries. The cheese fries were good, thank goodness because the Philly (1) had more lettuce onionsetc than meat which tells me next time just get the Philly, they'll have no choice but to give you more meat. As you notice onthe photo, you can't tell which is the Philly and which is the Italian. The meat has no seasoning, even a little salt would havehelped in my opinion, the bread was soft and lovely. I had to dunk in the ketchup and cheese on the fries to enjoy it. TheItalian was dry as well, no mayo? I know it was too have an oil of some sort but not sure if it was on there either. Oh well,guess i can say I tried them. No revisit need. Read more

CLASSIC CHEESE STEAK (wiz wit) PHREEDOM DOG PITT TWIST A bunch of great staff, that were very interactive and helpful with... recommendations. The bar has a good choice of local IPAs. I was actually able to smash all this food myself, just simply becauseit was that good. Drove 40minutes just to try this place.... it is now a regular must have when ever I am out this way. Read more

Incredible! I made this place my last meal before jaw surgery and it did not disappoint. Easily the best cheese steaks in... Indiana. One of the rare places that actually does whiz wit. Great beer too! Read more

This place !!!! We enjoyed this location even more than Virginia Ave. The owner was there working and instantly acknowledged us... as we talked w her at the other location (which is now permanently closed due to staffing and just general area issues.) Thislocation has alot more options as far as the food and extras. The owner is as much a reason to go as the great sandwiches sheserves up!! I got the original cheesesteak with white American and extra provolone. I got the small and could only finish half.My boyfriend got the cold cut and says it's the best in the city. He got the large and it was huge ! This ia a place we continueto frequent! Read more

Paid $7.49 for these pathetic ball park chilli cheese fries. Got a cheesesteak and didn?t even bother eating it nor taking a... picture. It was dry, unseasoned, the meat was fatty and overall gross! There?s no way you?ve had REAL cheesesteaks and enjoythis place. Over priced and just not worth it. We will not be back Read more