Reviews for Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR in Indianapolis, IN

The main area looks like any other college pizza by the slice place, but to the back left of the main restaurant is a hidden... bar. GREAT bar with Excellent Bourbon and Whisky selection. You can bring your pizza and super long breadsticks to the bar andhave a great time. Read more

HUGE pizza!!!! Very delicious!! I was impressed with the time it took to get pizza and breadsticks. Friendly staff and clean... restaurant. Also very clean restrooms. Read more

Visiting with a crew of five from out of town. They made the most delicious individual pizzas for us, got them out to our tables... in record time despite the fact that they had a huge number of people coming in. The speakeasy was outstanding, everybody in thestaff was helpful, personable and this is truly the best pizza I've had in the very long time. The five of us ordered different12-in pizzas to share with each other and it was really outstanding! Please, please please be extra nice to everyone on thestaff, they deserve your kindness and outrageously huge tips. Thanks for making our visit to Indianapolis memorable! You guysrock! Read more

It was right in the heart of Mass Ave . The atmosphere was fun with cool vibes. The restaurant was very clean. I went at... lunchtime. I ordered a $9 Lunch special that includes a very large slice of pizza and a side salad or bread stick with a drink. The service was great. The pizza is New York style thin foldable pizza slices. Read more

Seriously delicious pizza! Went for the cheese pizza and was not disappointed. Good crisp, fresh cheese, and just the right... amount of grease. Would love to live closer to this location just to eat more of this pizza all the time! Staff and bartenderswere pleasant and easy to talk to. I even got to try their in house peanut butter whiskey on the house! Easy 5 stars! Shoutoutbarstool sports and el Prez for reviewing this place and putting it on my radar. Read more

Goodfellas is my usual late night go to for pizza after being on Mass Ave. They close at 3am on Saturday nights. The pizza is... sold by the slice or as a whole pizza. Last night they didn't offer whole pizzas because the line was so long, and they wererunning out of slices. I ordered the pizza with pepperoni, sausage, banana peppers and jalapeno. It was good, but the crust wassomewhat soggy this time around...not crispy enough, but still good. The staff member makes the pizzas as you're standing inlike which is cool. The music at night is always good! Usually hip hop. But be prepared to stand in line for 5 minutes orso. There's seating inside and outside. There's also a bar area in the back to buy adult beverages. Read more

Been a good minute since I've had a good NY style pizza. This lived up to my expectations, and the breadstick was like 2ft long... and taste a bit like pizza king with similar cheese dip. Read more

Sometimes it can be hit or miss depending on how busy they are or how long that slice has been sitting out. If you get the... chance to order an entire pizza instead of just a slice you probably won’t find a better pizza anywhere else in town. We likeNew York style pizza and they do it better than anyone else in Indianapolis. Read more