Reviews for Geraldine's Supper Club & Lounge in Indianapolis, IN

Tucked away just north of fountain square, before Washington street lies a hidden a gem Geraldine?s Supper Club & Lounge. On... the drive down my wife is questioning where I?m taking her for our 6 year anniversary while we drive down East Washington streetand I am taking back roads like south street. As you pull up Im first impressed that they turned an old dive bar into a classyrestaurant but it?s seems to be the theme of the area. (Parking is on the street and the entrance faces north old wooddoor) When you enter, you get the feel of a fancy jazz club. We are taken up stairs to a corner table where I?m seated in thecorner facing the entire upstairs. I could take in the decor while I dine and see the venue like a VIP. Start to finish theservice was A++++++++++. The waitress was always there when I needed her, the bus boy was on it, and always had a fulldrink. The food was A+++++++++ ????!!!! There was nothing to complain about and everything was cooked to perfection. The beefWellington was phenomenal and my wife?s filet was cooked perfect. If you haven?t been go, treat yourself to excellent food inan historic part of Indy, and take a night out on the town! Read more

Husband and I were in need of a memorable date night and Geraldine?s has been on our list to try for sometime. We finally went... the other night and we were not disappointed. From the service, music, and food everything was top notch. We enjoyed the 50 daydry aged steak, 6oz filet, lobster tail, rosemary fries, and mushroom caps for our entrees. My husband loved the 50 day dry agedsteak and the filet was one of the best I?ve ever had, perfectly cooked medium rare, cut like butter, and tasted even betterthan it was presented. To end the night we had coffee service and crème brûlée. The crème brûlée ended up being the starof the show and the perfect ending to our meal. If I had a complaint, the only one would be the small size of the tables for 2.It was at times difficult to place everything on the table but that didn?t deter from the experience whatsoever. We willdefinitely be back soon!! Thank you Geraldine?s for a wonderful evening. Read more

50/50. Very limited parking. Great service. Pass on the tomatoes, we're not sure what they were supposed to taste like.. too... much water and juices left you with a stewed tomato? The asparagus was great! The ribeye was perfect... the lamb chops had tobe cooked more, came out close to raw. Beef Wellington I was confused about... Desserts were perfect. Yummy bread pudding andchocolate cake! Will I go back? Probably not. Not a bad place but not super great. Read more

The service was absolutely fantastic and the food even more so! We had the calamari (delicious!), French onion soup (he said it... amazing), a filet (chefs kiss), ribeye (another chefs kiss) with onions, mushrooms, and cognac cream (to die for). The sides wechose were the rosemary steak fries and steamed asparagus. Definitely a place to go! Read more

Great service at the bar. Excellent cocktails, good wine lists as well. I had Beef Wellington as a main. Absolutely fantastic! I... don't see this dish on a menu often and never in a solo serving. The hint of mustard over the beef and under a perfect pastrydough was it for me. Highly recommend and I will return. Read more

We stumbled upon this place and I can?t tell you how excited I am that we found this place!! We had such a great experience! We... did their coffee service and got some of their chocolate cake. They have live music and the service is just superb!! I wouldgive them 10 stars if I could. This is a MUST SEE if you are in the area. (get the cake!) Read more

This was a delightful experience, the food was great which was an expectation from what I heard before going. I will say the... beef wellington was underwhelming but I've never had it so was not sure what was expected it was tasty for sure. Crabcakes wereperfectly done. What really did it for me was the service everyone was very attentive and it was really enjoyable almostfeeling catered to. The visit was a real treat! Read more

I had Stephanie as my server and she did an awesome job. She actually made my Espresso martini! I had the Beef Wellington,... augratin potatoes, and the bread pudding for dessert! Enjoyed the jazz music immensely while having a relaxing evening. Read more