Reviews for Gatsby's Pub & Grill in Indianapolis, IN
Alright Gatbys. I tried. If you are from out of town, do yourself a favor and drive further to anywhere else. I used to come... here regularly until kitchen staff cut my pie and ate half a slice. OK, no biggie. Didn't go for a while and wasn't gonnacondemn the establishment over 1 bad experience (I'm sorry I deleted the pictures now) So after a few months, went back tonightto get another pizza. This burnt pitiful excuse is what they gave me. Oh and the bartender tried to sell me on it "that lookslike a good pizza. You designed it well" uh, ok,, I didn't design it to be charcoal though. And instead of taking ownershipeither time they tried convincing me it was fine. Do not go here if you want to trust the kitchen your food is coming from. Read more
I got really sick after eating her the atmosphere was great I think the food might have been a bit overcooked and I have a very... sensitive tummy. However the broccli they make was spot on and I am a ducker for a good vegetable. My group and I came on trivianight and that was fun! I didn't know that was going to be going on and we all had an absolute blast participating. Soatmosphere 10 out of 10 but food is ehhhh. Read more
Nice sports bar with a decent kitchen to prepare a good meal or snacks. Pleasant waitstaff. The hot traditional wing aRe... prepared as classic wings. Decent sized and piping hot! I really liked the Diablo pasta with shrimp, a fair portion for theprice and really flavorful. Read more
We walked here from our hotel. It looks like a hole in the wall place to someone not from Indy. We were hungry and had few... options. But let me tell you, the onion rings tasted JUST like you want them to taste. Super crispy on the outside and tenderand sweet in the inside. The potato skins were full of cheese and crisp. But the fried mushrooms were THE BEST!! They batterthem there. Not pre-frozen like some. They are so flavorful, crispy, and irresistible! Everything was delicious!!! And thebeers were good too. Read more
I found this place from a Groupon I had bought, but never had heard of it before. For starters, my waitress was super nice. I... missed the fine print on my Groupon that said ?take out only? and she allowed me to use it with a dine-in purchase. Thank you somuch for that, ma?am!! My friend and I went on a Friday and the best part was the karaoke they had going on. The atmosphere herewas really enjoyable. I will definitely go back! Photo 1: Lamb Gyro and tots The sandwich was good for a gyro. I was expectingthere to be a little more meat, but the flavor was definitely there. The tots were to my perfection - crispy but stillfluffy. Photo 2: Hot wings The wings were decent - nothing spectacular. They were a little fatty and we were expecting them tobe drenched in sauce. As you can see, it was just poured over. Photo 3: Poppers Their jalapeño poppers were delicious. My onlyrecommendation would be maybe do 8 per basket instead of 6 as they?re fairly small. I?d highly recommend as an appetizer though! Read more
Pizza was a very thin crust that was ok. Flavor was acceptable with a decent amount of toppings. It was ready fast, the price... was pretty good and it was very close to my hotel. The person on the phone taking the order was friendly as was the waitressgetting my order Read more
I always love stopping at Gatsby's! Sometimes it's just a beer sometimes we get dinner. They new (since covid) potato seating is... fantastic on warm nights! But in October the Halloween decor is outstanding!!! Friendly staff & good food & drinks, also! Read more
We were visiting from Wisconsin for a baseball tournament and this was in walking distance of our hotel. Food was delicious and... wonderful service. We went 3 nights in a row and everything was great each time. My only complaint was the way the boys weretreated by staff members and patrons. As they were 15, we had no idea they weren't allowed in the restaurant due to it alsobeing a bar. Apparently this a state law, we had no idea. We had 16+ teenage boys that wanted to eat there with us. One nightthey could because there was table available in the ok area of the restaurant?! But then they were yelled at for asking forwater at the bar or walking out of that designated area, which was basically right next to the bar area anyway. A parent wasyelled at for talking to her son, because they were standing at the pull tab machine. They were turned away completely thesecond night we went at 6pm. We just ordered out the third night. The restaurant food and wait staff themselves werewonderful. Read more