Reviews for Eddy's Neighborhood Bar & Grill in Indianapolis, IN

We went with a big group and they had plenty of servers to take our orders and keep our drinks refilled. Our group ordered a... variety of food and everyone said it was very good. We had an awesome experience and would definitely come back when we're backin the area. Read more

Not good at all. The food is less than mediocre and way over-priced. I had a bad feeling when I walked in and especially when I... looked at the menu. The menu even looked flavorless. For the sake of convenience and time, I went against my better judgment andordered the Mahi sandwich, only because it had Cajun seasoning. I will say that I ordered it without the pesto aoali, due to anallergy. The Mahi was dry and flavorless. Maybe it would have been better with the pesto, but I doubt it. The cottage cheese wasgreat. Luckily I had the cottage cheese, bc the only thing worth eating was that and parts of the hoagie bun. I had a $25 lunchtoday (with tip) and it wasn't even worth $5. It's been a long time since I have been in a restaurant that is so boring, andthose prices are outrageous for such bad food. Read more

Ordered a wedge salad and this is what I got. A wedge no Bacon hardly any tomatoes a few slices of onion this is not what I... expected or should?ve received for the price that I paid! Read more

Great food and service, went here for lunch, first time being here and saw how busy they were so felt like it must be good and... they did not disappoint, we had the chicken salad sandwich and the Mahi Mahi sandwich both were excellent, looking forward togoing back. Read more

First time visit & we weren't disappointed. Shane, our server, is not only a credit to his profession but a huge asset to... Eddy's. Attentive without hovering. I had the shrimp w/ Old Bay seasoning, with rice & green beans. The shrimp was deliciousbut the menu didn't specify "shell on" so imagine my surprise when I took a bite & got shell w/my shrimp! The green beans werefresh, garden green beans & very good! I'm not a fan of their rice, tho. Next time I'll choose a different side. My husbandhad the "Smokehouse" burger. He was impressed the burger was cooked perfectly to his request of medium. It had just the rightamount of pork, with the bbq sauce on the side, which he really appreciated. The side of sweet potato fries was very generous! Shane happily made a pot of coffee for him & when Shane noticed I was low on ice tea, he brought another glass, noting " we keepa pitcher of tea for refills but I noticed you use sweetner so I didn't want to mess with you tea to sweetener ratio!" Asimple, but much appreciated, & attentive gesture. We had an enjoyable late lunch, early dinner after an appointment in Fishers& we agreed we'll make the trip from Greenwood to Eddy's again! Read more

Nice place to sit outside on a nice day. I would avoid the street tacos. They were dry and the corn tortillas fell apart, making... it hard to eat. Decent kids meals. The rest of my family liked their food better than I liked mine. Read more

We had a great time here at Eddy?s! We loved the food and Liz?s suggestions. Got the best service ever even though the server... had way more tables than I?d be able to handle as a server. We loved the nachos, Cesar salad, tacos and fish! Lots of greatoptions and wish we had room for carrot cake because it?s the best here! Read more

The sloppy joe nachos were a neat sweet and tangy starter. The chicken salad, we weren't huge fans of it but it was a unique... twist on a common recipe. The buffiyaki chicken wings were sweet and mild and I really enjoyed them. (Pro tip, their ranch isvery good too). The bathrooms were extremely clean and smelt wonderful, they even had febreeze in the stalls. Our waitress wasnice, but unattentive and ended up leaving our cash payment on the table and leaving after waiting 20 minutes for our bill. Read more