Reviews for Catello's Italian Art Cuisine in Indianapolis, IN

Had the cheese wheel pasta, it smells incredible when it's cooking. The pasta is delicious, but it is so rich. I barely finished... my portion, my wife made it through 1/3 of hers and now has some great leftovers. We'll definitely go back. Read more

First time here for our anniversary and it didn't disappoint. Jessica was very knowledgeable of the menu and helped us every... step of the way. The food is outstanding and served nice and hot. The bonus for us was the live music. Nice trio, thatplayed/sang a classic variety. The atmosphere of this place is great. We'll be back for sure. Read more

Before I begin, let me say the restaurant interior is lovely. Tables are spaced appropriately & booths lining the sides of... dining area are comfortable. A nice touch for diners is the pianist playing softly while enjoying your meal. A few things I didnot like at a restaurant commanding high prices, (everything is ala carte), was the dirty mat at the front door welcomingpatrons to this establishment. The hostess should be dressed more professionally, as well. Our server was very enthusiastic, butinexperienced, leaning over the entire table to point out his favorite appetizer or entree. My friend enjoyed his meal & saidhe’d return. I might. Another disappointment - the owner or the manager did not make an appearance at our table, inquiringif we were satisfied with the dinner. I have never been to one of my favorite places where either one did not stop by to checkon satisfaction of the meal. Certainly, in the case of this new restaurant, an introduction would have been appropriate & mostappreciated. Read more

Wonderful service, the atmosphere and setting is perfect for a nice evening dinner. The food was well prepared and the drinks... top notch! What really set it off for us was the Saturday night we went there was live singing which was absolutely beautifullyfilling the place. All in all couldn't have asked for a better night out. Read more

The only thing great about this place was the service and the dessert at the end. We took my mom here to celebrate her birthday... and for the price I was really disappointed. My dish came out luke warm and was extremely bland. It was even recommended by ourserver. Haha. The gelato and cannoli were delicious and a great way to end the meal. Thank you. ???? Read more

"Questo ristorante offre vero cibo italiano di qualità. È anche meglio di molti ristoranti in Italia." Talking about authentic... Italian cuisine. My boyfriend is from Milan, Italy and he said this is by far the best Italian restaurant he's ever been to inthe country, even better than many of the restaurants in Italy. The owner/chef himself is from Italy too, he make his own pasta,sauce, pastries, and etc, from scratch, using certain ingredients from Italy. My boyfriend even commented that the tiramisu isthe best he's ever had, other than his grandma's..hahaha. Which says a lot. This is an authentic Italian restaurant, so doexpect to have the real Italian restaurant experience: such as a 10-15mins wait between each course. Take your time andappreciate the food. Highly recommend their pasta dishes, and desserts. I really can taste the difference between fresh madepasta and store bought. He walked out as a very happy man that night. Definitely will visit again soon. Read more

Ambience; pretty and nice even on the patio. Not much to look at from from outside. Service: pleasant servers, prompt easy... service, no mix ups I had the lamb, forgot to take pics. Nice presentation and very tasty, from the chefs menu. My companionhad the daily special and it was delicious as well. Lemon cake was a big shareable desert Read more

Love the atmosphere here, wait staff if very friendly the charcuterie boards are the beat in town. Fresh made mozzarella and... great aged cheese and meats. Nice wine selection, you can find and affordable wine from the list. Great Italian desert andcoffee selections. Our go to Italian restaurant in Indy. Read more