Reviews for Caplingers Fresh Catch Seafood Kitchen in Indianapolis, IN

I Highly Recommend anything on their menu! My husband & I has ordered a variety of items. Everything we have tried is absolutely... Delicious! This is a carryout only restaurant due to no room for dine-in. Read more

27.00 for 1pc fish and 1/4 shrimp dinner that was over cooked and way over priced. Fried way too long and fries more like chips.... Sad because this used to be my favorite fish place. 3 stars because the owner is a nice person but the food is not as good andtoo much money. Do not get the pineapple bread pudding. Soooo bad. Some kind on milky juice on bottom looked plae and completelydried out on top and brown. taste was not good Read more

I really enjoy their food. I have been here 4 times and the Catfish is ALWAYS seasoned and fried perfectly. I have never been a... tarter sauce person but their's is delicious! It is sweet, kinda like honey mustard. Definitely will return. Read more

Wow the name Fresh says it all! The place offers food that truly taste so amazing. Their special is Basa and their tarter sauce... really goes well with it! They also have a deli area and the smoked tuna salad? try it! It?s just so flavorful, simply great totake home and have on crackers. I must try when in Indianapolis area. Read more

Usually, I love my meals from Caplinger's, however today was not so great. First, if I have to pay .50 extra for extra tarter... sauce, and $1.99 for a 20oz BOTTLE of Dr. Pepper, I expect to receive my correct order. Not a 12oz CAN of Dr. Pepper, and noextra tarter sauce. I don't care how much it is, that's theft in my eyes. Now, let's talk about the mac and cheese. It had anawful odor, and some suspect looking specks. I instantly lost my appetite. This is so unusual for you all. I certainly hope thisthis is just a bad day. If someone at the Pendleton Pike location sees this review, start checking the food before you serve it.God forbid someone gets sick. Read more

Crab cakes are HORRIBLE!! You can taste the old grease they were cooked in!!! Not fresh at all, taste like they were cooked... yesterday and was reheated today!!! Same with the green beans, absolutely reheated!!! Waste of my money!!!! Read more

Definitely worth it! Amazing food and you get alot. Highly recommend! My picture doesn't do the sandwich justice. I cut into it... before I thought of taking the picture. But you can see it is overflowing with crab and cheese and goodness! Read more

Ordered the lobster roll today for lunch. Been wanting one of these for years. unfortunately the lobster meat was very bland and... had the same flavor as fake crab. Stale bun and the portion was very small compared to what they advertise. Disappointed. Hadto charge back my account to get a refund. Manager was very rude and couldn?t care less about the quality of their food. Read more