Reviews for Tony's Famous New York Pizza in Indian Harbour Beach, FL

Maybe answer your phone to take orders instead of letting it ring for 5 minutes straight, the. When you call back 8 times the... lines busy. Probably garbage pizza anyway Read more

My first time to Tony's pizza this evening was fantastic! Excellent pizza. Chicken parmigiana was outstanding too! Excellent... service. I'll definitely be returning to Tony's! Read more

I?m a local. The people leaving negative reviews are full of it IMO. On the rare occasion we have a problem with our order,... they?ve always made it right. This place is the real deal - authentic NY style pizza at a reasonable price. The employees arealways friendly. I can?t get over the reviewer who complained about the tiramisu being packaged. Lady, you?re ordering pizzafrom a gas station? lower your standards for desert LMAO Read more

Delicious pizza and one heck of a nice guy!! Gino was so kind and funny. Super helpful also. We've been ordering pizza from... here for years but never went inside. Glad we did!! If you're looking for authentic NY style pizza, this is your place! DELICIOUS! Read more

When Tony owned it it was fantasticThey have a sign out front that says world's greatest meatball sub.You used to get five large... meatballs in the sub it Was tremendous.Now the bread was hard as a rock.And you had to really look for the meat balls. Littlethin slices of balls. What a disappointment. That's the last time they have are business. Read more

Ordered a chicken parm sandwich and received a sandwich that was mostly bread and barely chicken. The calzone ordered was a... fried one not baked, and received a baked one. Tiramisu is a commercial store bought item not even remotely resembling thedescription. Save your money or temper expectations to not expect your food to match the descriptions provided. Read more

They got the best pizza around by far! All the employees have a happy and friendly disposition. I recommend the Greek Pizza,... Jersey White Pizza, Gyro, and Nutella Pizza with Strawberries. Read more

I eat here once a week. I love their white pizza. Usually get 1/2 white half meat, or staten island chicken supreme.