Reviews for Pitmaster BarBQue Company in Idaho Falls, ID
Sandwich was kinda dry but the service was wonderful. Their cornbread is was super dense but the BBQ sauce is top notch. Overall... pretty good place for food! Read more
My family traveled to Idaho Falls from Utah and came across Pitmaster BarBQue Co. It was our first time here and Porter was very... helpful and attentive to us. He helped us order some DELICIOUS food and brought all the sauces to our table outside so we couldtry them! Thank you Porter! :) I highly recommend! Read more
We tried three different meats, they were all dried out and I would guess were from the day before. Corn bread was good but... again cold and not fresh. Good thing the bbq sause is good because we had to use a lot of it! The pig candy was like over saltedjerky and we couldn't eat it. Read more
I liked this place when my old boss took me here. That is why I went back. This time I had lunch with my Dad. The brisket was... dry. Maybe it was old leftovers or it was originally overcooked...one of the two. Cornbread was cold. Ribs were ok. Mac andcheese was decent. It wasn't nearly as good as when I went the first two times. I don't know why it has gone down hill. Before Iremember it being busy. When we walked in this time, no one was there. Ya better fix it before it is too late. Read more
Great food! Enjoyed the pork and my wife enjoyed the Idaho nachos. We really enjoyed our time. Happened to come in and was the... only ones in the store so that was great! Customer service was friendly. One younger gentlemen was frequently on his phone whileat the register while we were deciding. Not very professional. The food is great but its not the best BBQ in the area. They havea signature sauce that's also good but again not the best in town. Read more
So the cornbread was good???? I wish they made corn pudding style too. I ordered a small pit salad on DoorDash and it was... alright too. The salad comes with fresh tomatoes , carrot pieces and cucumber. Not a lot of meat but I liked that. The timeswe?ve eaten in it?s a clean and cute little place. The meat is really tasty I?ve had it outside of the salad and it was prettygood!! Definitely worth trying :) in a good part of Idaho falls too near shopping places. Read more
I love BBQ and this place is sad. You walk in and see all the awards they have won and think you're in for a treat. You're not.... I've never had to guess on what was brisket and what was pulled pork because I couldn't tell the difference by looking orTASTING the meat. I was so excited to try this place but I left sad and hungry. The best part of my meal was the green beans.The "pig candy" like eating a greasy, honey drenched stick. I've never had bacon so hard. Definitely not worth the price. Aftertrying my friend's ribs, I think I'll go have a McDonald's McRib sandwich before I consider coming back here for BBQ. Also,ketchup should not be the first ingredient on all of your BBQ sauce ingredients. In fact all of the BBQ sauce labels are exactlythe same. The only reason I'm giving this place 2 stars is because the staff was extremely friendly and great at their jobs. Read more
Why is it so hard to find good bbq in southeast Idaho?! Went to Pitmaster BBQ in IF tonight and we were not thrilled. Not only... did it take over 20 minutes for our food, but it was very average at best. Ishould have got the clue when we walked in by howfew people were there. The guy at the register didn't greet us at all and hardly recognized we were there. My son had aburger, was supposed to be one of their popular ones, with onion rings. Onion rings were an up grade as well..... he got 6small onion rings. I had Robs favorite, I think that's what it was called. Tasted okay but has about 2oz of brisket on it. My wife said her burger was dry. Then the soda machine went out of service so our drinks were 1 and done. With our food, we gota portion cup with sauce and something white blob in it? Not sure what it was. I would rate it a 2 out of 5. Read more