Reviews for Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Huntersville, NC

I bought 4 smaller pies an a large pumpkin pie. The filling was great and got even better after 7 minutes in a 400 degree oven.... I'm not giving them 5 stars because I think there's room for improvement in the crust. I think it's made with vegetableshortening only and I prefer a buttery flaky dough. Also the ratio of crust to filling is, in my opinion, is a little off. Don'tget me wrong though, these are top quality pies and very tasty. I will visit again. Thanks! Read more

Cute pie store. Similar setup to the Bundt Cake shop but with pies. Todays taster sample is Apple. Nice to get an idea of crust... and flavors. Bought two mini pies a pecan and a berry. Can?t wait to see how they taste. They have bread board outside withthe flavors of the day. Do yourself a favor and try a pie today. Read more

It was soo good. I got the coconut cream and yasss! I am in love with this small pie! Whenever I'm in the area. I will make sure... to come back to this cute little shop. ???? Read more

Thank God Huntersville finally has a shop that makes pies. I started going when they opened last year and have frequented them... on many occasions. They are reliable, very nice/pleasant and make awesome pies????. I don?t know if I have a favorite. I thinkwhichever one I?m eating at the time is the winner????. My daughter?s favorites are the Caramel Turtle and the I40 (partial piepicture). The other 2 pictures are the Apple Pie and the Chewy Chocolate Chip. Read more

I'd been wanting to try these pies so the free birthday pie coupon they sent me was the perfect excuse to come up here. I... decided to get 3 of the 4" mini pies: Blackberry Custard, Southern Custard, and Apple. So far I've only tried the BlackberryCustard and I loved it. The crust was pretty good and the filling was delicious. I'm looking forward to trying the rest. Read more

Awesome experience today. I popped up to use my welcome to the Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Club free mini pie with the purchase of a... mini pie. I was greeted by very sweet employees that were telling me all about the pies and their favorites. The addition of apie shop in Birkdale is just a perfect thing! And with the holidays just around the corner, get your orders in and these pieswould make great gifts! PS I brought home pumpkin and apple pies & they were both so D E L I C I O U S! Read more

When to Charlotte for the weekend for a renaissance fair and I stopped at this place every night of my trip for dessert. First... night I got the Peanut Butter Cream, second night we got the Key Lime and the I-40, BOTH were amazing to enjoy. 5/5 This placeis a MUST EAT if you're in the area!!! Read more

The people at Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop really know how to make pie. I saw an add for them so I went to their website to see what... they were all about. I found out that if you sign up for their Pie Perks Club you get a free 4" pie. So I did that and we boughtanother one and three of us splitting the 8" of pie was more than indulgent. These pies are rich, sweet deliciousness. We triedthe key lime, which is my husband's favorite kind of pie. He judges everyone he tries against mine ???? and I'm happy to saythat we will be getting that one again. We also tasted the I-40. That was good too but I think, for me, with pecans andchocolate and coconut and the brown sugar of the pecan pie filling, it muddled the flavors a bit too much. But I'm excited totry all of the other flavors. Read more