Reviews for Otter Creek Sports Bar & Grill in Hortonville, WI
Super friendly staff. Excellent Broasted Chicken ar a good price and interesting pizza - add cream cheese. You got to try them... if you are in the area Read more
Came for lunch. Very understaffed with one waitress, but she was definitely doing her best. Very overpriced, about $20 per... person. Was served frozen mozzarella sticks. I ate them anyway because I am shy and a lunatic. One of the best Reuben's I haveever had. Read more
We had a group of 6.The mixed drinks were bad. The service was prompt, but a couple of the oders were wrong and the "kitchen"... tried to blame it on us.The waitress came back twice to dispute the order and finally put in a new order for the correct food.The food was mediocre at best and definitely not worth the hassle. No one in the group will be returning. Read more
Delish! Food. Working my way through the menu. i have tried their baked haddock, grilled chicken, loaded Mac and cheese, Birdie... wrap, and chicken salad. All have been amazing. Great food, great service, and great owners. Read more
First time there. Food was delicious!! I had the ribeye sandwich cooked medium rare. Was SO good. Very juicy. Cooked perfectly.... Had onion rings with ranch dressing on the side. Very good!! My husband had the walleye dinner with fries. He thoroughly enjoyedit as well. Service was good and staff was friendly. Would highly recommend!! Will go again when we are in the area!! Read more
I love going to this place. The people are always friendly and engaging and the food is delicious and the menu has quite the... variety to it. I recommend Otter Creek. Read more
Super friendly service and great food. We had some pretty awesome cheese curds as an app and I had the Club sandwich and my... husband had the Philly. Both were amazing. Was our first time eating here and will definitely be back :) Read more
First time we visited, and it won't be the last. Wonderful waitress and delicious food with large portions.