Reviews for Black Otter Supper Club in Hortonville, WI
This is by far the best place for steak and prime rib in the Fox Valley. Any steak I have gotten here you can practically cut... with just your fork. Another thing that really sets them apart is there soup and salad bar, especially the clam chowder. Eventhough it is not self serve, they still give out very good portions of everything, it is almost a meal in and of itself. Read more
I'm absolutely in love with this place's prime rib. I got the king cut which is a 72oz and it was some of the best prime I've... ever had. The service was amazing, and all the sides (mashed taters and clam chowder) were to die for as well. The price wasthe best part. I look forward to coming back and trying the rest of their menu. Read more
Had a great meal with a bunch of friends. Wait staff was very nice. Began with the soup and salad bar which was a good start and... for the main course I chose the queen cut prime rib which you can see by the photo is anything but small. Plenty for leftoversthe next day. Read more
Our favorite supper club in the state. Fantastic steaks. Legendary salad bar. Great drinks. Usually a pretty long wait, but... certainly worth the wait. Get there early. Read more
Drinks and food were great. Service was warm, welcoming and consistent. Bluegill (pictured) was good. Only small disappointmemt... was in the serving size of the potatoes puffs. Seems like everyone that ordered fries or skins got a heaping pile and puffs youonly get 6 that are the size of a green olive. It would be nice to get the self service salad bar back but I get it with covidand everything lingering. I just imagine the 3-4 employees working the salad bar could be so much more useful being utilized asservers or busers. Read more
This is the go to for us. It's a hard choice between Black Otter and the Pine Tree but man the black otter does steaks like no... one else. I ended up trying the ribs and holy cow where they good and HUGE. The half rack is big the full is a beast. You won'tbe disappointed from the food to the staff you'll get nothing but the best. Read more
Hands down, best Prime Rib I?ve ever had. Salad bar was phenomenal. Nothing negative to say about our experience here. The wait... was well worth the quality and the service was second to none. We will definitely be back! Read more
Absolutely phenomenal Supper Club. There's a reason people from not only the state, but across the country come to this... establishment. I ordered the "queen cut" Prime rib, which was a 32 ounce cut. That's 2 pounds of meat on your plate! Trust me,I'm a big eater and I couldn't finish the first 10 ounce. Also the Salad bar was *chef kiss ???? It's all you can eat for saladand soup, and they make your custom salad right in front of you. Everything was fresh and you get almost every condiment underthe sun. Worth every penny and you'll leave with left-overs, I guarantee it. ???? Read more