Reviews for Fat City in Horseheads, NY
We are from NC and BBQ is a main food group for us! We are here visiting, saw this place on google, and decided to try it out!... BEST BBQ we have ever had! Everything we ordered was delicious! The service was phenomenal too! We were checked on multipletimes and our food came out fast! Loved every bit of this place! Read more
So lucky we stumbled on this place for lunch! I got the burnt ends and they are perfect! Tender, but still nice and smoky. All... the sides were amazing, I got cornbread, mac and cheese, and collards. Never had collards prepared quite like them, so good. Prices are very reasonable for barbecue. Read more
Found this place by trusting reviews on google maps and it did not disappoint. Fat city BBQ was easy to locate. They had a... variety of options on the menu. We went with the burnt edges and ribs. Both dishes came with a large quantity of meat anddelicious. The burnt edges were packed full of flavor. The ribs were cooked to perfection, falling right off the bone. For sideswe selected the baked beans, chili, macaroni salad and callord greens. The baked beans were dynamite, the chili was flavorfulwith a touch of spice that hit just right. All beans were tender and hot, cooked just right. I hope this review doesn't detereyou from going, but helps the owners to do better where they can. If they don't know- they can't make a change. The macaronisalad was my least favorite item. It was a basic salad but a bit dry, and lacked flavor (compared to the other menu items). Itneeded more mayo, dill maybe, some salt and pepper to taste. The collard greens were different but tasty. They were cooked withTurkey, tender and popped in your mouth but they lacked something. Maybe some crushed red pepper would have been inviting? Thecorn bread was on point. It wasn?t sweet, but exactly how corn bread should taste. To complete our meal we ordered dessert togo. Peanut Butter pie, that was rich and tasty and the Chocolate Hazelnut Pie that was just like biting into a velvety FerreroRocher! I'll definitely be back to try more off the menu. This is a great BBQ spot, possibly the best in the area. Worth thestop to try. The decorations are tasteful and the restaurant is immaculate, it makes you feel that they care not only about howyour food taste but the environment in which you eat your food in, and where it's cooked. They even have t-shirts for sale!Support small businesses and get here! Read more
Heard good things so I had to check the place out. It?s small inside but incredibly clean! They clearly care about the quality... of their food and establishment. The burnt ends and Mac and cheese I got were delicious, as well as the corn bread (it?sactually some of the best I?ve had!). Employees were polite, took my order quickly and got my food to me hot and fresh. Highlysuggest this restaurant if you like good BBQ Read more
We saw the reviews on the place and had to try it. It was so tiny and cute, and the decor was exquisite, my favorite was the fat... Mona Lisa! We got the brisket quesadilla, with cheese and mac, with some pulled pork. The pork was absolutely delicious, and themac n cheese was heaven! My husband loved the quesadilla, we will definitely be back! They even gave us some corn bread on thehouse, the best I've ever had, 100% recommend! Read more
It?s hard to find good bbq in this area. This place outdid itself! Their is a lot of options to chose from and decently priced.... This is definitely a hidden gem in the Horseheads/Elmira area. Customer service was awesome, answered many of the question wehad. They went above and beyond for us! Will definitely visit again. Read more
I got the sampler platter. It's not on the menu but I guess they have been asked for it before because it is in the computer. It... was smoked turkey, brisket and pulled pork with a side of brisket chili. It must of been good because I ordered sausage andburnt ends to go. They were a good midnight snack. My wife got the creamy cheese n mac with pulled pork. She liked that. Read more
I rate a BBQ place by it's brisket, and this place nails it! Perfect texture and buttery fat, it was delicious! The burnt ends... were fantastic as well. The cornbread was light and fluffy, I devoured it We loved the BBQ beans and the chili sides. Macand cheese wasnt bad but it wasn't anything to write home about... If I'm ever in the area again I will definetely stop in Read more