Reviews for Rico's Pizza New York Style in Hornell, NY
First time trying pizza and wings. My family loved it all. This is our New to go place for pizza an wings. Will try other... options from now on.. best experience. Read more
Calzone with ham and veggies. Bland, sauce was in a small jar and also bland. Bread just bread. Nothing on it. Plain. I expected... a lot more flavor. Cinnamon knots were very good. I saw flies on the slices sitting on the counter. Read more
Finally got to try this place and I think it's pretty delicious!! ???????? not gonna lie, the wings were pretty good...but the... thing that REALLY Bugs me is, when ya mess up and there's absolutely NOBODY inside the restaurant, barely anyone ordering, staffis standing around doing NOTHING and STILL mess up!! HOW!?!?! I had ordered boneLESS wings and got bone-in...wow..can't even getwhat you ordered correctly! The stupidity I tell ya! Smh....thanks anyways guys! Read more
We visited this place by accident and I am glad. The owner was there and he suggested a couple of good vegetarian options and we... agreed. The Vegetarian pizza with fresh jalapeno on top was the BIGGEST WINNER. We are from NY/NJ so we know the real taste andThis one is in the race. Read more
Haven't tried the pizza yet but the calzones are amazing. Came back a second time and they didn't disappoint. Staff was... friendly. The cannolis are the best I've had outside of a Italian bakery. Not sure why such low reviews from others but Idefinitely disagree. Read more
I personally love the chicken wing pizza here and their garlic knots are great only reason for 4 stars over 5 is because of the... price but the quality met more than my expectations! On the normal pizza(other than chicken wing) I?d just recommend gettinglight on the cheese unless you like extra as there was a bit much but you?d expect that from New York style. Read more
just tried rico's and had a great experience. went inside and the guy who took our order was nice and helpful with the menu for... it being out first time. our small pizza and half dozen garlic knots were done in about 15 minutes. guy who handed us out foodsaid that some people had complained about their pizza being squished in the box, so he showed us how he put it in and closed itbecause made our small pizza on the bigger side which was super cool of him. had to drive 30 mins home and the food was stillwarm and delicious when we ate - the sauce on the pizza is sweeter (which I love) and the knots were some of the best around.will definitely be coming back for more! Read more
No one has left a review for a while but they must have gotten way better because their pizza is outstanding a bit oily but... super amazing and if you haven't tried the Cajun Knots yet I would definitely head down there ???? I only ordered half a dozenbut they were probably the best knots I've ever had, you guys are doing great ?? thank you for the amazing food! Read more