Reviews for Michael Anthony's Pizza in Homosassa Springs, FL

Authentic, thin, New York style pizza with great sauce. Every pasta dish we've tried has been A+ We also highly recommend the... calzone.... it is delicious! And, to top everything off, they're open later than any other Italian restaurant in the area. Read more

Stopped in on my way home I?m not usually in that area but man was I glad I did. It?s so hard to find good pizza where I live in... Inverness but the drive was worth it. Pizza was cooked to perfection the only thing missing was a little more oomf which was myfault i forgot to ask for breaded chicken vs regular chicken. The pizza would have been a 12/10 if I asked for breaded chickenand I won?t make that mistake next time. Very friendly staff and quick service. Nice display case with fresh pizza on displayand a view of the kitchen from the front counter which everything looked clean and sanitary. Pretty nice location next to Publixnear Homosassa trail. Wish they had a second location in Inverness or even lecanto. The penne on the pizza was cooked well thevodka sauce was so delicious I can?t rave enough about the combination. And I purposely saved two pieces to reheat for lunch thenext day and I throw it in the overnight and it was even better the next day. If you?re on the fence about trying it or lookingfor a new pizza place make sure to check them out. Great quality!! Read more

The pizza is really good. Seems like a NY style crust. They do sell by the slice, and typically offer six choices when I've... wanted in. First time I went in, I ordered double sausage with mushroom, and the buffalo calamari appetizer. Both wereexcellent. I've since had their pasta, and more than a few soups of the day (shrimp bisque being my favorite). The prices arereasonable, and the staff is friendly. Read more

10 in personal Pie and drink 16.00 dollars. Sure looks and smells good! Clean place and nice people. P.S.I am going to do better... about taking pictures. After 14 hr. days and 11hrs of driving the last thing I want to do is take photos. Read more

Have Always loved the food (Pizza & spinach roll)however yesterday my friend ordered a Pan Pizza (Square) and I a spinach roll.... I pick up my order (should've checked) when I get back with the meal there was a large round pizza , my friend calls MichaelAnthony's and spoke with the girl who took his order and said this wasn't the Pan Pizza, she said, " oh it's the same" we itisn't the same, 1. It's not square and thick, it's round and thin. 2. There is most definitely a price difference. So it's notthe same. Paid $37 and change for a round large pizza and spinach roll. But of course nothing was done as this young, very youngminded lady could not admit there was a mistake, so we've been coming there for a long time ,but won't be back for anythinguntil there are mature personal. And it wasn't cheap either. I don't like to complain I'm not like that, but way to much money,especially when times are tough for everyone. Read more

This pizza is delicious. I just got cheese. A good cheese pizza is all you need to know whether or not a place is good. The... crust was excellent. The sauce was excellent the whole experience was excellent. I just ordered a reheated slice instead of awhole pizza. I can only imagine what a whole pizza baked fresh would be. Because this was seriously great pizza. End it was only$2.50 I think? Read more

Stopped here after a recommendation from a local. The loaded bacon fries were a hit, the portions are exceptionally generous,... the service was quick and friendly. I had the meatball sub and the Meatballs tasted very processed, definitely freezer to table.The Stromboli was very greasy and the pepperoni took over the flavor from all other ingredients. I probably would not come back.They have a large menu so there could be some other gems in addition to the fries. Read more

I should have trusted my instincts upon seeing a wide range of reviews and skipped this establishment. But no, I forged ahead... with reckless abandon to the detriment of my taste buds to whom I owe a heartfelt apology. Some cite a crispy crust, I beg todiffer and found it to be a dry chalky crust devoid of any satisfying flavor. The utter lack of cheese caused the underlying redsauce to percolate to the top and evaporate away and ultimately produce a shriveled up mess. I hope my taste buds will forgiveme in time. Read more