Reviews for The Monster Crab Juicy Seafood & Bar in Holtsville, NY

Best Cajun Boil in Long Island. I?ve been here three times in the last two months and each time each entrée was prepared to... perfection. Give it a shot, guarantee you will not be disappointed. Read more

Came here for the first time after finishing a movie close by. The interior is really nice and clean. We happened to be their on... Tuesday so had two 1 1/4 lb lobster specials which came with corn and a potato. We had the butter and garlic sauce which wasquite delicious. We also ordered combo A, fried oysters as an appetizer and a couple of drinks. I was pretty impressed overalland it was also happy hour so look forward to trying other entrees the next time we go. Read more

My husband and I tried this place tonight. We absolutely love it! My husband had the clam bag with Cajun style spicy. He also... has the chicken wings Cajun. I had mozzarella sticks, New England clam chowder, and the shrimp basket. Definitely will be backhere again. Read more

The entire experience was ok, the food met my expectations. The lobster deal was cool $20 whole lobster with corn and potatoes.... Everyday a new deal so choose wisely. They have a nice food presentation at the table. None of the staff was stand out just ok.We dined outside. No music and the atmosphere was bland needs Decora and music, in my opinion. Never sat indoors. No wait andparking was easy. Give it a try Read more

In town from Florida for a funeral. First time eating at this place. Reminded me of a place we have back home in Fl. The food... was awesome. No other word to describe this place. Restaurant was clean & the staff was very friendly. I would definitely checkthis place out. The garlic butter sauce was soooooooooo gooooood!!! It was so good I had to buy a 2 lobster tail meals!!! Read more

Service was great. Polite, attentive and helpful. I ordered combo B with shrimp, black mussels, and crab legs with garlic... butter sauce. It was amazing. Portion was great, could not even finish half. I Will for sure comeback. Wonderful experience. Read more

Had a craving for crabs legs so we decided to try Monster Crab. I had 1lb snow crab cajun season mild and a side of sausage.... FLAVOR!! Everything on my plate was delish and good portion. Mrs. had a combo crab legs, shrimp, and mussels garlic butter mild.She was extremely happy with her meal. Staff was prompt and friendly. Will be returning soon! Read more

I truly enjoyed this food! writing this on Monday morning please forgive me. Went on a Friday night wasn't packed which was... great. our server forgot her name but she was great. me n my wife got the create your own boils. they had good flavor I choosethe garlic butter mixed with Cajun sauce. in my opinion the garlic butter sauce doesn't shine through enough for me. it alsowasn't enough sauce for my boil. I added pics, I got a good amount of seafood maybe add extra sauce. I eat out alot at manydifferent places an this sauce is good just wasn't great. you know some places part of the boil can be overcooked NOT hereeverything was cooked to perfection. just my drink boy my taste buds didn't like it think it's called zombie or something Iforget. really wish the garlic butter tasted more "garlicy" ??????????? with all that said we'll be back in a couple days. Read more