Reviews for Subway in Holtsville, NY

Found out after arrival that no people are allowed in the store. Had to down load the app and make the order. Order was prepared... wrong and I double checked receipt to confirm.. not worth the hassle Read more

So wanted a tuna hero. Oh my goodness aside from my homemade tuna it hit the spot. Green peppers and red onions springled... lightly.... Read more

Ordered a foot long All-American with everything on it with mayo and banana peppers. I got 1 slice of ham, 1 slice of turkey, 1... slice of bacon, not lettuce tomato or anything it comes it, but the guy did remember the mayo and banana peppers. Unbelievable. Read more

I don't know if there are new owners or new workers but this place has really gone down hill. I ordered from here all the time... and for the last few months they are always out of ingredients, they get orders wrong. When you go to pick up the workers arguewith you about what you ordered. For instance "you can't get two cheeses on one sandwich" when I have placed the order onlineand paid extra for a second cheese which is an option. They tell you they are out of the cold cut combo when not only is itavailable to order online but they also have all the ingredients in the store and refuse to make it for you because it's not amenu option according to them -- again I was able to order it online. Even if it wasn't, it's not like no one has ever builttheir own sandwich at Subway. I've been doing it for decades. Done with this particular store. Read more

Not the nicest location I've been to and the restaurant looked as if it was closed when I pulled into the parking lot. The open... sign was not on and I didn't see anyone inside. When I walked in a young gentleman helped me out, he was quick and definitelyhooked my sandwich up which made the stop there very worth it. Great service, but turn your open sign on so people who pass byknow you're open. Read more

I am a regular at this subway and I must say that I love this place! The staff is AMAZING and does everything to pure... perfection. True sandwich artists if you ask me. Fresh product that always tastes amazing is only served here, no stale food atall unlike some other places. 5 out of 5 stars. Read more

It used to be a very good option, but the new staff do not add the ingredients sufficiently. Multiple problems -They dont heat... the food enough in the oven -They go very light/easy with the toppings -they go easy with the sauce One can't telling them,please add a little more for everything. Eventually, you will have a Luke warm bread with little hint of other ingredients. Theycan easily not go this path. Get through staff back or please train the new staff better The place is always clean. That's thereason I go Read more

If I could give zero stars I would. This location is the worst . I used the Subway app at 11:30 to get my sandwich at 12:30 for... my half hour lunch break. The two sloths behind the counter didn't get to it and i had to burn 20 minutes on the line for themto make it. I will NEVER go here again. and Corporate is sure as hell getting a complaint also. Read more