Reviews for The Blind Pelican Seafood House in Holly Springs, NC

Hands down the best Bloody Mary experience ever! Everything was delicious. Steak - cooked to perfection and cut with a butter... knife. Crab legs - meat comes out of the shell whole. Oysters were salty and on point. Bloody Mary had just the right amount ofspice, flavor 10 out of 10. I want to go back tomorrow. ???????????? Both the bartenders and our waitresses were awesome. Couldnot recommend more. Read more

A great place to eat with courteous staff who are coming to your table regularly to see if you need anything or refills for... drinks. They seat you promptly. The side dishes were very tasty with Cole slaw served in a traditional NorthCarolina style. The fried okra was hot and very tasty. The buffalo shrimp appetizer with blue cheese sauce was very good. Ihighly recommend it. Also,The Salmon was good, but needed less salt in the seasoning on top of the fish. Otherwise, anexcellent eating establishment with reasonable prices and bang for your buck on food served to the customer. Definitely will goback again; So go to The Blind Pelican for great seafood and sides and I here the drinks are phenomenal. Read more

Our second time dining there was great. The wait was an hour so we sat at the bar, which was fine. My wife and I bought the... Medusa which looks like the picture I've uploaded. Everything was cooked perfectly and tasted great. I feel 100 dollars is a bitmuch for the food included and we had to get more food to feel satisfied. The smoked old fashioned was amazing, though expensiveat 15 dollars. Overall we would go back, but over $170 for two people without an appetizer or dessert is steep. Read more

I found out about this place via Facebook months ago and my friend and I finally made it there today! SO GOOD. The cocktails... were beautiful and delicious; the food even better. We had buffalo shrimp app, a Bloody Mary and added scallops per our server?srecommendation (Josh - there are multiple Josh?s he said so he is ?medium Josh? - he was WONDERFUL) also had ?Casino? oystersand hush puppies. YUMMM! Everything was so tasty, we will definitely be going back soon and will ask for medium Josh! Thanksfor a great dining experience! Read more

I have to say the drinks and atmosphere was great. The food was decent, but didn?t give us the wow this is delicious. (Gator... bites were on point!) mac-n-cheese need some help. Mahi-mahi was alright but didn?t have the grill taste I was looking for.Steak was cooked perfectly and tender, but needs some seasoning or something. I have to say it wasn?t crazy busy (2-3:30pm),wish the drink service was faster, having a party of 7 we thirsty. It happens but the server also spilled water on 2 of us onaccident, most of the others went on the floor. First time I have experienced that. Also SUSHI nachos are only after 4PM!!!! Ireally was looking forward for them. Growing up at the beach, I?ll keep this place in my back pocket but definitely needs someimprovement. Not trying to sound to negative here just being honest! Read more

We are still new to the area and discovering places? this is at the TOP of our list to revisit! They have a take on bourbon,... similar to a Bloody Mary! We ordered a 15 year bourbon with a Filet because we couldn?t leave without trying! THIS PLACE ISAMAZING. Go when they have their sushi nachos, if you?re a sushi fan? they?re incredible. Every table had them, and weunderstood why! Their oysters were phenomenal. Scallops, Snow crab legs, sweet potato waffle fries, and those hush puppies? HOLYMOLY. Excellent bourbon selection too, easily a spot we will be taking visitors! Read more

This place was amazing! Went here for our anniversary dinner and between the food and customer service, they did not disappoint.... I ordered a medium steak which did come out smothered in some type of gravy that was not listed in the description of the mealbut luckily the gravy was pretty good. We also had one of their famous bloody Mary?s. Truthfully the drinks are a bit priceywhen looking at it in paper but once it comes out and you see all the food involved with it then you?ll understand that theprice is fair. All food was seasoned well. There was a small hiccup with my steak but it was corrected very quickly! Wedefinitely will be returning! Read more

Great place for a party. Staff was fantastic, large seating area. If you want outdoor seating come early. Good selection of... seafood on the menu, but some veggie options along with the trusty burger. Full bar, large beer wine selection! Service wasreally good and food came out faster than we thought. This would have been a 10/10 but wife's pasta was warm, wish it was hot..Still going with 5 stars. We will be back. Read more