Reviews for My Pie Pizza in Holladay, UT
My Pie is one of my favorite places for a personal pizza. They have a great selection of established styles or you can create... your own. You can also customize the styles they already offer. They also have a few different healthier crust options as wellas salads calzones and don't forget to get a fresh cookie! Read more
The pizza was absolutely fantastic!!! The employees were fantastic, the speed of service was fantastic. Gave 3 stars because... while trying to eat it must have been lunchtime for the middle school, felt like we were eating in the lunchroom. The noise wasunbearable. Apparently kids aren't taught manners over here. It was ridiculous! The staff could have possible asked them totone it down. Read more
This is a really unique pizza place. It's unlike any other pizza I've had. I've been trying different things from the menu and... have liked it all. I always get the garlic knots though and love them. My girlfriend says they are too garlicky, but that's whatI love about them. I always go in to order Togo and it's made and cooked and ready to eat in under 10 minutes. I think I'll gofor lunch today. Read more
TO GO ORDER: Maybe it was because our food wasn?t fresh but for one the pizzas were tiny for their pricing being $12-$14 for a... medium size pizza. That?s expensive when the flavor is not there. My kids did enjoy the garlic knots but even those had a lot ofgarlic in them. Lastly the wings were slightly overdone because mine were dry and had no flavor of spice. I ordered the oneswith heat and their photo showed they were in a sauce and mine were dry rubbed; two totally different things. Not impressedbased on their average score. Read more
This is our first time at my pie pizza. We love the atmosphere, the location and the food. We got the NY Roni and the margarita... pizza. The pizzas were cooked to perfection and the flavor was amazing. Felt like I was getting a homemade pizza. I would givethis place a try If you are in Holladay and are in the mood for some good New York style pizza. Read more
Decent pizza, I was suggest getting the well-done crust other than that it will be a little bit Dowie. The margarita pizza sauce... is a sweet sauce. The New York style pizza was good. Read more
GET IT! Soooo delicious and tasty . OOh my goodness I would have given this place 10 stars if I could have .I definitely... recommend trying sliced almonds on your pizza of choice !!!!!!! Soooooo YUMMY!!! ???????????? Perfectly cooked and all specialinstructions followed to a T! Great priced, HOT, prompt phenomenal mouth watering GOODNESS! DEFINITELY MY PIZZA PIE and my ONE &ONLY PIZZA PLACE NOW! ????. Read more
I just had my first experience at My Pie Pizza and based off of my time here I can confidently say I will be back. The food was... delicious! The crust was crispy and soft at the same time and the toppings were juicy. Also the Motif of the restaurant wasexquisite! This place is SLEPT on. I had the privilege to meet the owner greg and he was a very pleasant man. He went out of hisway to provide my family and myself with the best experience possible. I believe he is the man for this job! Shoutout to thecrew working at night on 11/11! Read more