Reviews for Nicolo's Chicago Style Pizza in Highlands Ranch, CO

We used to get really good pizza from this place, but the last few times have been disappointing. The delivery was fast on our... last order, but the pizza had raw dough as it has had a few times previously as well. Sadly, we need a new go-to pizza place. :( Read more

Great tasting pizza, dough has a nice crispness. And the price is perfect especially for quality and freshness I Will definitely... order again. Read more

First time trying this place. The food tastes good. I made a custom deep dish pizza with sausage and pepperoni. Tbh, there were... hardly any toppings. For the price you would expect them to put more inside. You maybe get one or two pieces per slice. Also,the pizza wasn't cut. By time I got home it was difficult to cut through. Overall, it's not worth the price for what you get.Yes it tastes good but could be better quality and just not worth it. Read more

We had a large group (13) and there was another large group that came in at the same time as us. Service was great. Ava was a... fantastic server. A couple of little hiccups, but they made it right. Whole staff was working hard all night. Pizza and pastawas great! Read more

Pizza wasn?t terrible. Minus one star since they charged 3.5 for toppings that were basically non existent (see photo). A couple... of fresh tomato slices and maybe 10 minuscule pieces of burned basil. Couldn?t taste any of it at all. Minus another star sincethey never gave any option to replace provolone cheese with mozzarella on any of their pizzas. Had to order something we didn?twant since it was the only pizza that said it had mozzarella. $23 for this medium pizza (and we did carry out) Read more

We tried Nicolo's after receiving a coupon in the mail. We are so glad we did. The pizza was outstanding. The EBA (basically a... Supreme pizza) had loads of toppings, nice crust, and tasted great. The veggie pizza was similarly tasty. The large can easilyfeed 3-4 people. I picked up our order, and the staff were friendly and helpful. We are so glad we found this place. It willlikely become our go to pizza place. We are looking forward to trying other dishes in the future. Read more

If you go here for pizza, get the deep dish(still pricey for the quality), don't bother with thin. These are pictures of their... 'thin crust'. They should have specified 'thin', as this couldn't pass for more that a flimsy piece of cardboard which tastesexactly how it looks. True Chicago thin would laugh at this, as even Chicago thin(Rosati's, Lou's, Giordano's, Ginos East,Pompeii, etc) still has very good thickness, double/triple of Nicolos thin. Had I known prior it was $13 for this grocery storeTombstone I would have laughed. In addition, upon calling to put in my order I was placed on 'hold'(hung up on) twice before asuccessful third call, and they completely botched my phone number. What if they wanted to get a hold of me after the order toask if I wanted my thin crust any thinner?! I feel bad for that guy if they called him.. Good thing my friends weren't veryhungry and had most of the deep dish to myself. Just sad.. Read more

What great tasting pizza! We had the Chicago deep dish and it was fantastic. Can't believe I haven't eaten here before now. ... Wait staff was friendly and the place was clean. Had a fine town feel to the decent sized dining room. Food came out hot. Price was comparable to other non-chain pizza restaurants. Read more