Reviews for Salvatore's in Herkimer, NY
The chicken riggies were excellent as well as the service! Portions were huge!
I ordered onions petals however I received onion rings. Ok.. I ordered chicken tenders no sauce they put sauce in the container... without the top securely on and it was a mess. My kid wouldn't eat it. I called them. No apology or offer to make it right and Iorder from there at least 3xs a month if not more from a business stand point that's not to smart. The combo I ordered had 2mozz sticks 4 onions rings and 3 tenders which were pieces of tenders not whole pieces for almost 10.00 I was disappointed . Read more
Had dinner ordered for pick up from here (7/25/22). We ordered a large pizza and 30 everything wings and an antipasta salad.... When we received our order, the wings were not crispy at all and there was not any sauce in the containers. The pizza looked andtasted old. The antipasta was half full. When we called to complain, the owner was very rude and gaslighted us and said "we onlycook the wings long enough to cook them through, if you wanted them crispy, you need to ask for them crispy and ask for extrasauce." After we drove down for the second time, we arrived to pick up the sauce, the owner continued to be rude and handed ustwo wimpy containers of sauce, all the while he said "I have been doing this for 30 years, I know what I am doing" and claimedto tell his staff to add more sauce to the containers. I would not recommend this place at all. Their service was horrendous andthere are plenty of other pizzerias in the area that you can go to that offers better quality service and food. Read more
Visiting from out of town and the family wanted some delicious pizza for dinner. There are three pizza places in town to choose... from and one was closed. Based on other reviews and photos, we chose Salvatore's, and so glad that we did. We ordered Cheese,Garlic, and Meat Lovers pizzas and all of them were outstanding! Can't wait to visit again. Read more
Cute little pizza place nestled in a beautiful area! Food was delicious and staff was great! The server was triple sat the... moment we sat down, so we expected to be waiting a while.. not the case at all! The server was attentive, knowledgeable andfast! We were in and out within an hour or so! Read more
Best homemade pizza I have had in years. The sauce was fresh and flavorful, the crust was golden brown and crisp on the bottom... but the inner crust was light and airy, with a hint of sweetness. Worth the time to dine.. Read more
Really had an enjoyable quick meal. Staff were very courteous and my steak sandwich was delicious. The roll was toasted and... topped with garlic butter and parmesan. The roll was crisp but nice and light. Fries were crispy. Perfect! My bride had amediterranean sandwich which she enjoyed. Grandchildren enjoyed their meals also. Read more
Pre-note, I only get takeout from them. Generally, the food is good, but how well its prepared swings quite a bit. You'll get a... chicken parm that's fairly decent one time, then the next the container will be full of the water used to cook the spaghetti, ornot enough sauce, or the amount of chicken included is halved. It's like 50% of the time there's some really low-hanging fruitthing they could have done to not make you miserable. Nice owners, good recipes, but hit and miss execution. Read more