Reviews for Tully's Seafood Market & Snack Shack in Hampton Bays, NY

Save your time, your appetite, and your money by going somewhere else- anywhere else. There was only one other couple in the... restaurant yet it still took 35 minutes to serve the worst lobster rolls I?ve ever had in my life. They were rubbery and tasteda week old. You?re forced to buy two at a time and can?t choose 1 hit or 1 cold. Bathrooms were disgusting and it was overall abad experience- wish I could get my precious minutes of vacation back and money. I don?t post often but this experience drove meto post. Read more

It's all about junk food. I rode my bike with some friends from the city and wanted a decent place to eat for lunch. We got the... pression to be ripped off. Our food was only "junk food" at a very high price and we struggled to get tap water. I personallyhad the Mac and Cheese as I am vegetarian and i felt it was not "home made". Read more

Stopped there after riding 32 miles on my road bike for a salad and a fried seafood combo. They weren't busy (which I should... have picked up on). It took about 20 minutes to get my food. I substituted the fries for a side salad. The salad was very good. I can't say the same about the combo platter of fried shrimp, clam strips and flounder. The shrimp was fried batter with thetiniest about of actual shrimp. There were only a few clam straps and the flounder was ok. For $30, I was expecting it to begood, but, it was fair at it's best. Read more

Decent food but lobster roll + conch fritters and a Bud light was $95. I was told it was two lobster rolls but more like 1... lobster roll spread out over two buns. Food was tasty but not tasty enough for a paper plate joint to warrant that pricing. Read more

Stopped in the market to grab some fresh fish on the way home from the beach and spontaneously also got a Qt of Seafood Gumbo.... Let me tell you my tastebuds were sent straight to New Orleans that gumbo was so good! 10/10 would recommend! Read more

This fish market and restaurant makes the best lobsters on the eastern south fork. 3 & 4 pound were steamed and delicious! We... did pick up and brought them home as we are still not eating at restaurants yet because of the new virus variant. Cannot bebeat! Absolutely delicious! Read more

Really nice staff and you get double the amount of food compared to other places. Had the lobster rolls and they came with... waffle fries so what?s not to love Read more

Amazing little stop on the way down to the beach! We went twice, first for soft shell crab sandwich - it was great. Second time... we got the hot lobster roll and it was full of tons of lobster meat that was succulent and delicious with the perfect amount ofbutter! They also have canned alcoholic beverages and mixed drinks like margarita and sangria perfect to bring back with us tothe hotel after. Read more