Reviews for Out of the Blue Seafood in Hampton Bays, NY
Was quite impressed with Rumba restaurant when i visit Hampton on my first day. Thought i should give other places nearby a... chance. However I was left quite disappointed with Out of the Blue. Crab cake is not bad but is quite overpriced. Seared MahiTuna came out quite cold, arent fresh or soft but taste like hard cardboard sadly. For a $26 salad, I was hoping the tuna wouldtaste decent but it is nowhere compared to the seared mahi tuna from Rumba next door. Wouldnt mind spending close to $50 if thefoods are at least palatable, but instead went home feeling disgusted after eating that nasty Tuna Read more
If your looking for great fresh seafood then this is the place. We came here as a group and there was plenty of seating... available. Great spot if your looking to eat in or take it home. I love how light and creamy their New England Clam Chowder was. Read more
We go every week never had a bad meal food is on point staff is great specials are worth it
This place is absolutely amazing everyone was very kind that worked there. A few tables and chairs inside also you can pick up... raw sea food to go. Food was very fairly priced and some of the best I had the whole time I was in the Hamptons. Read more
Easily the best fresh and smoked fish and shellfish restaurant we've come across on LI. Everything you want from the sea,... steamed to perfection and served piping hot. But don't, don't sleep on that smoked fish. Rivals anything from the pacificnorthwest, rest of the east coast, and across the pond. Go ahead and pay $28 for a lobster roll elsewhere on the island, butthis place has an abundance of great tasting and absolute quality fresh seafood at very decent prices. Truly a hidden gem. Read more
Priced slightly higher than you'd expect for a seafood market / restaurant, this place is laid back and casual, with a fresh... seafood flair. My spouse and I got the New England Clam Chowder, the 1/2 Hot & 1/2 Cold Lobster Roll, and the Sauteed Cod. Allwere tasty. Service was a little slow to refill our water, but everything else was fine. Read more
Lobster bisque was quite nasty. It was super thick and tasted like butter and flour. I did enjoy the one small piece of lobster... in the bowl. The seafood combo was quite disappointing. For $25 you get three small shrimp, three clams, 3 scallops and a 2ozpiece of flounder with two sides. That was like $4 worth of seafood at the market. What a rip off. I left hungry. I gave ittwo stars instead of one star because the seafood was at least tasty. Read more
Some times you just gotta take the time to treat yourself to something nice. Well deserved lunch