Reviews for Hampton Bays Bagel in Hampton Bays, NY
Probably the best tasting breakfast bagel, egg & bacon sandwich EVER! Very friendly counter lady & gentleman cook! We're heading... back soon for another DELICIOUS sandwich! Read more
Had a very bad experience on a recent Soup Takeout order They left bayleaf in soup which lodged in my throat had to go to... Emergency Room as i was choking. Leaf came loose and i lived They cook their soup but didnt remove accessory ingredient I haventbeen back since Read more
The sandwich that I got here was delicious, however there was a little mixup; the server gave us a bagel with just an egg on it.... It wasn't a big deal, but I figured it was worth mentioning. This is a very popular place, so be aware of the long lines!! Read more
The food is always good and they are very accommodating with their service. Their prices are excellent. When the pandemic... started, this was the first small business I saw that had gloves, masks and boxes of assorted vegetables and staples for peopleto buy. An essential business. Read more
Very conveniently located on Montauk Highway, this bagel store has very good bagels and they're served fresh. I had a lox &... cream cheese here and the serving size was generous for the price. The coffee is also very good, so I recommend this place ifyou're in the mood for a decent bagel while in the Hamptons. Read more
I came here with a group of friends for breakfast on a Sunday morning. There were so many great bagel options as well as... breakfast sandwiches. The service was quick and the food was made fresh. The everything bagel is salted, which I love, and theham and eggs I got on it were perfectly seasoned. Definitely recommend coming in for breakfast! Read more
I've gone here a few times to get my usual order of bacon and eggs on a plate. I've been mostly happy with the food, but... sometimes the meal looks and tastes like it was prepared in a rush. The last time I went, I had to put a bit of effort intosawing through the scrambled eggs with the plastic utensils. The bacon has been hit or miss so far. When the bacon is doneright, it's crispy (but not burnt) and delicious. On one occasion, however, it tasted as if it was pulled off of a shelf andtossed in the microwave. The interior is pretty nice; there's plenty of space between each table, and everything is alwaysclean and orderly. There's not much space around where you place your order, but at least you can wait at one of the tablesuntil your food is ready. The price for my food has been consistent across all three visits, which is extremely rare as far asmy custom order goes. The staff has been very nice and helpful so far as well. I'm sure I'll be back sometime soon after anothermediocre workout at the Planet Fitness next door. I want to give this place a higher rating, so I definitely want to try thebacon and eggs a few more times. Read more
Every time I order something they never get it right, I order egg sandwiches and they give me pancakes I ask no pepper, and they... load up on pepper, and much more. Read more