Reviews for Simply Italian Bakery (SIB) in Hamilton, ON

I was on Ottawa St. today with my son and stopped into the bakery to check it out. I settled on a loaf of sourdough bread to... bring home. We all had a slice with our lunch and it was thumbs up all around. I'd say it's the best sourdough bread in thecity. We will most certainly be returning. Read more

Bright modern shop packed full of old world food! Beautiful baked goods case with treats to tempt you, so delicious. A wood... fired pizza oven turned out the best Margherita pizza while we watched, to take home for lunch. My two and a half year oldgrandson downed 3 pieces, if that isn't the best testimonial ever! Other breads and foccacia look amazing, that's on the listfir my next visit! Read more

Had a lovely time at SIB yesterday afternoon. Staff was extremely friendly and food was quiet good, dessert especially! The... bathrooms were clean! Interior of the place was homey but pretty minimalistic. SIB provides a wide array of items such as:Pizza, Bread, Cakes, Cookies, Coffee (Iced and Hot) and even Gelato! Read more

I cannot recommend this place enough, the baked goods transported me right to the best bakeries in Italy, paired with an iced... coffee, the perfect treat, the pizza, even the day old $2 slices are so good, the limade FORGET ABOUT IT. I've been in Hamilton5 years now and I'm kicking myself for not finding this place sooner. Read more

Recently ordered a 12-in pepperon pizza($20+tax).Really bland and under cooked. To top it off didn't have much flavor. I could... have gone to Little Caesars and gotten the same size pizza with three toppings for under $10 and it would have tasted better.Should have known better when I saw the price of a butter tart, four bucks can you believe that for a butter tart. I highlydon't recommend this place. Read more

First time in Simply Italian Bakery and YOU have to go! The ambiance is very welcoming and charming. It?s the cutest little spot... with amazing food. The pizza focaccia and the strawberry butter cream cake is to die for. IT WAS FIRE!! They also have pre madefood for takeaway. Oh and don?t forget desserts great selection of pastries and gelatos. The service we received was so amazingand we will definitely be back again. They made us feel welcomed and gave us an amazing experience. Read more

Super talented pastry chef! Their cakes are not only beautiful works of art, but so delicious. Highly recommended.

Stopped in for something sweet after some burgers. What a cute little bakery! The breads on the shelves looked so fresh. All the... treats are as aesthetic as they are tasty. There's a sitting area if you decide to have your meal here. I only ordered achocolate covered strawberry (which was delicious) but I'd definitely return with an emptier stomach to indulge myself. Thestaff are super friendly and helpful, and the store is spotless - not a speck of flour out of place! Read more