Reviews for Eli's Brick Oven Pizza in Hamden, CT
Liked the open concept at first with their indoor dining - But found it extremely weird that we couldn't order a large pizza... just because we were dining in vs. take out. Why?!!? Pizza was okay - sauce tasted different. Honestly left pretty disappointed Read more
My loves it here, with kids we usually order half cheese and half bacon. (One kid only wants cheese) we were excited to eat in... the newly renovated dining room and now you can only order personal pizzas, had to spend way more than what a normal large pizzathat we usually get would have cost us. Kinda of a scam if you ask me. Read more
Last week my wife and I went to pizza restaurant to eat in. I ordered a large pie and was told only small. We were shocked to... hear no more large pies will be sold here. When I asked the cashier why?, he said money. Very poor company practice. Also, newinside of restaurant very cold compared to previous set-up. Read more
1st time eating Eli's pizza it was good hot fresh delivery pizza not sure what some of the bad reviews were about but some... people are stuck on frozen grocery store pizza can't please them all Read more
I?m new to the area due to working nearby and was recommended Eli?s for pizza. I was skeptical at first being from NJ about... other pizza places from out of state. Ordered a basic pie to be on the safe side. First bite blew me away! From freshingredients to the crust and excellent flavors I will have to say it?s the best pizza I have ever tasted. Whenever I?m in thearea, I will make it a regular place to get pizza from. They have so many other items I would love to try. Glad I was introducedto this place. Puts NJ pizza to shame! Read more
Ordered from Eli's for the first time tonight. My grilled chicken and pepperoni pizza was excellent. I'll definitely be ordering... again, and will post the pictures as I do. Read more
I got there right near closing time, and ordered the meatball parmigiana sandwich. It was pretty good. The restaurant is very... clean and has a cool aesthetic. The meatballs had some big chunks of garlic in it, and one of the meatballs was crunchy, like ithad been freezer burned and then cooked. Read more
Food is delicious, both their sandwiches and pizza! However, it is a bit frustrating that every time I order take out, the food... takes significantly longer to be ready than the time I?m given over the phone. I feel like I?m always waiting at least 20+minutes for the food to be ready after I arrive. Additionally, would be nice if you could order large pizzas for dine-in. Read more