Reviews for Yellow Belly Ice Cream (Seasonal Apr-Sept) in Hailey, ID

Oh my gosh! We came up to here from Eagle, newly from Hollywood and thought how amazing would this be to sitting down and have a... quick refresher. We gave our 3 orders and the young lady scooping was such a pleasure and very polite. I thought what a greatexperience and then I went to pay, the girl was in a half top and her belly was sticking out, that was NOT PLEASANT? she wascounting back my change and I told her ?if you start with the $1s it is so much easier, old school way ????? Her came back was?I have been doing this a long time and I know what to do!? WOOOOWW I don?t think I have ever been treated so rudely by a persontaking my hard earned money.. good luck with that service and her dress ethics showing her belly to the public. Read more

Always a great place to stop by and get an ice cream!

I've tried ever single flavor of ice cream at Yellow Belly. The best ones have got to be Cookies n Cream, Brownies On The Moon,... and Coconut Castaway. Honorable mentions for Cake Batter and Cotton Candy. Make sure you tip the employees well, because no oneever tips, and they don't get paid nearly enough. Read more

The kid over charged me then argued with me about it. I explained to him what the sales tax is here in Idaho and it's not 25%.... He apologized and I told him to put the $1.40 in the tip jar and let it be a lesson learned to be cautious of what your chargingyour customers and what your then putting into your tip jar after they walk away. Read more

Fun ice cream shop just off the beaten path. The ice cream was good but there weren't a lot of options. The tables outside were... nasty and we had to ask to get them cleaned. Read more

Great little ice cream shop with plenty of flavors. They have sorbet, so some dairy free options

The ice cream is great, bit pricey. Wonderful little shop. We went with friends and all our kids. The staff seemed bothered by... having to do their job of scooping ice cream for customers. Read more

Best ice cream shop! The staff is friendly, prices reasonable, and it supports the local community. I keep telling the owner she... needs to carry cake batter ice cream. Maybe one day Read more