Reviews for Cafe Italia Restaurant & Pizzeria in Hagerstown, MD

Ordered the Fettuccine Alfredo with Broccoli for delivery. Awful, just awful, as a real Italian I am insulted, disgusted, how... dare you. You know what you did. Read more

Online it says they deliver. And then when you call to place a delivery the staff is very rude when ask to place a delivery.... It?s interesting because I?ve picked up doordash orders from this location. At the very least they could?ve recommended their3rd party delivery service but instead I was met with a stern we don?t deliver. Don?t recommend. Read more

We arrived with a very large group and despite being understaffed for the occasion they handled it very well. Waiters were nice... and food was well made. Read more

Went in for the dine in area. Not only was the waiter and cook the sweetest people I?ve ever met but they seemed to know... everyone that walked in the door and made everyone smile. The food was absolutely amazing and I will be coming back often ?? Read more

We feel bad for the restaurant. We come in and spend $35 more worth of food and they find it necessary to charge for a couple... extra pieces of bread not only that they charge 4% processing fee to use the credit card system. We've been going there foryears the food is always excellent but they must not be doing well to start nickel and diming the customer. Thinking that theycan charge extra for a couple pieces of bread is only flattering themselves and insulting the customer.. the bread is not thatgood. Read more

It was full of a local Italian charm. It had Italian music playing at a perfect level. It was not too large, very cozy and... intimate. Only one waitress for floor but she was very personable and relaxed and took good care of everyone. Loved the pizza, Iam a crust girl so two thumbs up there. My hubby got a sub and the freshly baked on site roll was amazing. We also had theshrimp basket which came with fries and it was crunchy and well seasoned. It was an overall enjoyable experience and willreturn. ???????? Read more

This is a nice place and I was quite surprised. Our waiter had wonderful customer service skills. We ordered a stromboli and an... Amalfi salad which was delicious. The balsamic dressing was fabulous. I only wish I had room to try some of their desserts. Read more

My family and I just moved here and we were looking for an awesome pizza place. Well, we found it. The food was amazing. We got... strumboli, subs, pizza, and the best thing I've ever tasted-crab fries! The crab fries had real crab meat smothered in cheese ontop of cajun fries (that's what the spice tasted like). Oh my goodness. There was also an awesome garlic ranch served with thefood. They are worth the price. The staff was also excellent and the place was very clean. The prices were a little bit higher.However, the portions of food quickly made me forget the price. Read more