Reviews for Papa Kelsey's of Hagerman in Hagerman, ID
I love Papa Kelsey's toasted subs! I usually get the toasted ham and cheese or the steak, but opted for ham and turkey this... time. Their fries/sauce are a must, and sometimes I'll make a visit just for those. Read more
Ordered a pizza for Carry out after work and toppings were added that wasn't supposed to be on there, when I got home I called... them back to make it rite with no answer, they never called me back after leaving a vm either. This would be the 3 rd time I'vehad wrong toppings on my pizza. I ordered the Fred's delight and they always be putting onions on it . Probably done with thisplace from now on . Read more
Wish they paid a little closer attention to special requests. Two out of two times "sandwich no tomato" has ended up with... tomatoes... Food is otherwise good and people praise the pizza, but what is the tomato pushing agenda? Read more
Italian Combo Sub is just as good in Hagerman as Twin Falls. One sub is enough for two people. But I can wolf a whole one down... so fast I'm just miserable afterwards. The pizza looked really good but I just can't not order an Italian combo. Read more
Great sub sandwiches on homemade bread! Huge menu selection. We had two subs to go for a picnic. They were wrapped in foil so... they stayed hot. Everything was reasonably priced. I HIGHLY recommend this place for friendly, fast service and great food! Read more
My family and I stopped for lunch today on the way home from camping in Hagerman. We were immediately surprised when we walked... in. The place looks small from the outside but was quite spacious inside. The decor was clean and modern but felt very homey.The menu was full of choices but we went with your basic pizzas and a burger. The food was very good but the older gentleman whobrought it out to us was not friendly at all and acted like we were awful people when my daughter asked if she could get a sideof ranch with her pizza. Hoping he was just having a bad day and doesn?t always act that way to customers. Other than that, weenjoyed our meal. Read more
Love this place! I stop every time I pass through Hagerman. Their subs are awesome! The place is always clean, fast and... courteous service. Save room for some ice cream for sure! Will be back! Read more
Have eaten here a couple of times in the past and the food was decent. I had finger steaks which looked like something else... than finger steaks. They came with onion rings which were cut way to think so didn't cook properly. Husband had a hamburgerand his comment was next time we eat at McDonald's (which is in the Loves Truckstop at the interstate). Read more