Reviews for Benny's Pizza & Italian Restaurant in Guilford, PA

The pricing on the menu is not correct. The waitress said that everything went up a dollar. Although mine had went up $1.75. ... The money is not an issue. The issue is that they need to tell customers this when ordering or get new menu?s. I just wonderif the price was a random draw from a hat. Nothing like a surprise when the bill comes. Read more

Order the steak and cheese and it was just that a steak and cheese nothing more nothing less. The bread was very good and the... meat was dry and way too much pepper. It would have been nice if lettuce tomato and mayonnaise was added to the sub. The order Iordered online was supposed to be ready at a certain time I waited that time and went to pick up the order but when I got therethe order wasn't even started and I had to sit around in a cold waiting area. I would suggest calling in the order. The jury isstill out if I'll return or not. Read more

Great food and prices. Definitely will be back! Food was excellent! Each dinner comes with garlic bread and a salad. Pizza was... also great! Read more

Must have new ownership, the food has changed for the worse. Benny?s used to have a unique thinner crust, great sauce, and light... on the cheese. Now it?s nowhere near the same. The pizza is just another pizza joint pie, nothing special for the price. Largepizza and 2 mozz sticks was $30. The mozzarella sticks are just frozen store bought and baked in the oven. Not real deal deepfried mozz sticks. Very disappointed. Rumor has it the same people also bought Franks Taste of Italy in Mont Alto, and theirfood has suddenly become equally disappointing. When it was the real Bennys and Franks, both places are top notch. Now both arehorrible. Won?t be back to either. Read more

Not sure if ownership changed but sure seems like that way. Ordered Margherita Pizza, pizza came to the table as a cheese... pizza, no fresh mozzarella dollops and zero I mean zero sauce. The crust was flavorless, dough was certainly not the same as Iremember. Also ordered steak fajitas and quesadillas which weren?t bad but also not great either. The service was also slowand waitress keep bringing us wrong refills. The A/C must have been broke because it was just as hot inside as outside. Unfortunately my family will not be coming back to Benny?s. The quality, service and experience has changed for the worse. Sadto see such a nice little restaurant decline. Read more

Driving home w/ the kiddo and found this place open. We were both hungry and craving some classic pizza w/ a good crust. Didn?t... disappoint! ?only wish they?d had a beer license. Read more

Had lunch there today. Always good. We usually get take out but today we ate in.

Fantastic food! Each meal that was ordered was fresh and delicious. Will return again for sure!