Reviews for The Frisky Oyster in Greenport, NY
So coming in being in the service industry, I like to give a little bit of grace. Our appetizers were great. Server was a bit... ignorant on the wine list. We ordered the $250 wagu ribeye medium rare and it came out cold and inedible. It was freezing andextremely rare. We sent it back, and it came back the second time microwaved. $250 wagu in the microwave? Unacceptable. The chefbrought it to the table and was inhospitable, unaccommodating and basically told us that it was cooked how we asked. We willdefinitely not be back to the frisky oyster, as we?d prefer to eat oysters on the side of the road, and a steak from asteakhouse where we trust we are getting what we pay for. Would have given 1 star, but our server was sweet and we know staffingis hard right now. Read more
Amazing date night dinner! Everything from the wine to the duck and halibut! Must try the peeko oysters !! We had two orders!
I?ve been here multiple times, but tonight was the first time I?ve been here in nearly a year. I waited over 30 minutes for a... drink and they gave me the wrong one. My entree arrived soon after and I wanted to have a red wine while I eat and they refusedbecause I haven?t finished my first drink which I just received. The bartender then got in a public argument with another patronwho wanted a drink because they had their young son with them, even though he wasn?t at the bar. I?ve never walked out of arestaurant before, but this is the closest I?ve ever come to walking out. I certainly will never go here again. Read more
Hands down the best restaurant in Greenport. My girlfriends and I stayed for 4 nights, tried all the local spots, and this was... by far the best. Their widow's hole oysters friskafella is to die for! But not only is their food incredible, but theirhospitality is even better. My friend?s mom had surprised me and ordered a bottle of champagne for us to celebrate and this wasthe cute little note they did. They went above and beyond making my birthday and our dining experience so memorable. Can?t waitto come back again! Read more
The service was amazing and so professional ?? we were seated immediately and had a beautiful dinner. It is pricey and I think... some of the food came out more warm than hot. Drinks are also $15-26 for cocktails. Atmosphere is pleasant and it was a niceplace. Oysters come a bit small and the sauce is more on the sweet side. Read more
Jack and Diogo took great care of us. Seated on the front window, we enjoyed our curated cocktails and delicious selections... from. The menu including lobster quesadilla, crispy tuna spring rolls and baked oysters. Yummy. Looking forward to returningagain and again. Read more
The atmosphere is great and the food was amazing. Having gone now that restaurants are finally open post-covid shutdow , all of... the staff was doing a great job with wearing masks and gloves; the seating seemed to be at half capacity as well. They wereaccommodating with food allergies and the vibe was very relaxing. All staff were so polite and friendly. Will definitely beback. Read more
The most consistent, high quality kitchen in Greenport. Prefer to sit at the bar for a livelier experience but there are also... lounge seats by the windows or tables tucked away for a more private experience. Great cocktails. Staff is fantastic, friendly,knowledgeable and professional. It is expensive, to be sure. Prices went up during COVID and seem to have stayed. Read more