Reviews for Monical's Pizza of Greencastle in Greencastle, IN
![](https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/mfcollectnew/reviewIcons/google.png)
Beware! If you haven't been here in awile things have changed. They used to give 8 pieces of garlic toast with cheese... w/sauce..but now you get this for $7!!!... it's literally a hoagie bun cut into 8 thin [like breadsticks] pieces! What a ripoff.. I thought they made a mistake but when I called the store the guy said ..well we've changed some bread & that was ALL Igot...a hoagie bun for $7 Read more
![](https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/mfcollectnew/reviewIcons/google.png)
Waitress was very nice. Gave my son and I super service. House family salad was fresh and plentiful, pizza was very good.
![](https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/mfcollectnew/reviewIcons/google.png)
Pizza had good flavor but the thin crust was just to hard to eat. Service was great
![](https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/mfcollectnew/reviewIcons/google.png)
Good pizza with friendly service. They were very accommodating even for our large group we had. The service was quick and we... were very happy with every. Read more
![](https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/mfcollectnew/reviewIcons/google.png)
To be honest, I seldom visit Monical's. It has nothing to do with their service or food; just not a huge pizza fan. But there's... one dish i DO go there for. It's a nostalgic thing to sit down for Tortelloni, as I did with my late grandmother. Yes, I knowthis is a sappy review but does that make it any less valid? There's very few things that can make me nostalgic about anythingfrom my childhood but I have very many fond memories from within those walls. And I'm happy to continue making more memorieswith friends & my children. Read more
![](https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/mfcollectnew/reviewIcons/google.png)
Drove from Bloomington to eat at my all time favorite pizza place for father's day with my dadI grew up in Illinois and when we... moved to Bedford/Bloomington IN., Was devastated about not having a monicals pizza. I've eaten a lot of pizza throughout my 44years, and nothing has ever come close to beating Monicals pizza! Staff was awesome, clean environment and delicious pizza Read more
![](https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/mfcollectnew/reviewIcons/google.png)
I've ordered from here quite frequently. Never had any issues. Unfortunately, today(4/7/22) is an exception. Ordered a... buffalo chicken sandwich and a side of blue cheese dressing. Well.....no dressing anywhere. Sandwich appears to not have anycheese. Bread is burnt. Sandwich is dry and just not good. Not sure what happened, but I hope this isn't the new standard. Yikes. Read more
Love their pizza and it?s an easy in and out for dinner.