Reviews for Monical's Pizza of Greencastle in Greencastle, IN
Beware! If you haven't been here in awile things have changed. They used to give 8 pieces of garlic toast with cheese... w/sauce..but now you get this for $7!!!... it's literally a hoagie bun cut into 8 thin [like breadsticks] pieces! What a ripoff.. I thought they made a mistake but when I called the store the guy said ..well we've changed some bread & that was ALL Igot...a hoagie bun for $7 Read more
Waitress was very nice. Gave my son and I super service. House family salad was fresh and plentiful, pizza was very good.
Pizza had good flavor but the thin crust was just to hard to eat. Service was great
Good pizza with friendly service. They were very accommodating even for our large group we had. The service was quick and we... were very happy with every. Read more
To be honest, I seldom visit Monical's. It has nothing to do with their service or food; just not a huge pizza fan. But there's... one dish i DO go there for. It's a nostalgic thing to sit down for Tortelloni, as I did with my late grandmother. Yes, I knowthis is a sappy review but does that make it any less valid? There's very few things that can make me nostalgic about anythingfrom my childhood but I have very many fond memories from within those walls. And I'm happy to continue making more memorieswith friends & my children. Read more
Drove from Bloomington to eat at my all time favorite pizza place for father's day with my dadI grew up in Illinois and when we... moved to Bedford/Bloomington IN., Was devastated about not having a monicals pizza. I've eaten a lot of pizza throughout my 44years, and nothing has ever come close to beating Monicals pizza! Staff was awesome, clean environment and delicious pizza Read more
I've ordered from here quite frequently. Never had any issues. Unfortunately, today(4/7/22) is an exception. Ordered a... buffalo chicken sandwich and a side of blue cheese dressing. Well.....no dressing anywhere. Sandwich appears to not have anycheese. Bread is burnt. Sandwich is dry and just not good. Not sure what happened, but I hope this isn't the new standard. Yikes. Read more
Love their pizza and it?s an easy in and out for dinner.