Reviews for Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant in Green Bay, WI

Sammy?s Pizza was amazingly good. Even better than the pizza was the service. Absolutely felt like I was at home here. Highly... recommend!!! Read more

What a joke. Absolutely terrible. I haven?t had this bad of an experience in a LONG time even post Covid with short staffing... everywhere. Our waitress never came back after giving us drinks. Not once. We got no refills, no check ins, nothing we asked forfrom her. She seriously never even came back with our bill. We had to go explain to the guy at the checkout, who looks to be amanager of sort, where we were sat so he could find our bill. Mind you I explained to him that we had no bill bill because ourwaitress never came back and his only response was ?how was everything??. Are you serious? It was terrible. Your pizza wascompletely burnt all except for the very middle few slices, your house dressing tastes like pure salt, and I have to go pullanother waitress aside for any help at all. The only decent thing we got was water and a side of pizza sauce. This guy didn?tseem to care at all. The prices are way overpriced for garbage burnt food and even worse service. We expected long waits walkingin as it was very busy, but this was unacceptable. I?m so glad we don?t live here. I?d be ashamed to call this a local eatery. Read more

Wow! We were walking towards our hotel after the game (a dreadful loss) and needing an Uber. Stopped in for a slice. The... place was packed, as expected, so I was expecting a 45 minute wait but we were seated immediately!! I love how they work here(and how hard)! We had at least 4 people serving and checking in on us throughout our meal. Pizza was good. Toppings were sofresh. Loved the choice of cheese! Service was prompt, we didn't wait for anything and they were slammed!! Salads werefantastic!!!! Read more

We parked here for the Packer game. $20 for parking comes with a $20 food certificate. We got large pizza. It was good, but not... exceptional, It seemed a little pricy at $27 overall. It was cut into squares. The toppings were of good quality. We enjoyedour experience and would dine again. Read more

Yes yes yes a million times yes. Go there now! Pizza was AMAZING. The crust was crisp and delicious. All the way cooked not... doughy at at all. The pasta was the absolute best. Pene is hard to cook and they nailed it. My pasta baby needed unzipping atthis one. Read more

The food was delicious, but let me tell you even If it wasn't I would return solely based on how hard the employees work and how... incredibly nice they were! They go out of their way to answer any questions and just all around make sure you have a pleasantexperience. Great food! Even greater staff! Clean! Timely and organized! Homemade items, not some corporate boxed item forprofit on your plate! Personable! I didn't catch everyone's names, but our original server was Justin when we stopped in therethis afternoon around 2 or so, they all tended our table though. If I could have given the place more stars, I would have. Itwas worth every penny and then some. This type of customer service is hard to find anywhere. It is a top notch performance!! Ihope they are all paid and appreciated properly as they should be!! I look forward to returning. (Cheese Ravioli, cheese bread,and a pizza for my teenager with an insatiable appetite ????) DELICIOUS. That sauce.. holy heaven!! Keep up the great job! Read more

The pizza was fine. Was I jumping up and down when I took a bite? Nope, its just fine. It?s not the best but I can eat it. The... best pizza I?ve ever had is Old Worlds pizza! It?s super good! ?? But that pizza place is all the way in Minnesota? Read more

The service is always great and their pizza is delicious. We?ve tried several different things off the menu so far. Our favorite... was the Alfredo pizza. Their bowl of chili is the best I?ve ever tried ???? Read more