Reviews for Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom in Greeley, CO
they served me a dirty plate. the food i ordered was family size so the plates came staked and when i went to share the plates... were dirty… the server ( blond girl + big eyelashes probably like 35 ) didn’t believe me?? i took a pic before getting themanager bc she was really rude (tossing my silverware and sauces on the table?? like ??). i would recommend calling the healthdepartment before eating here. Read more
Went there for a dinner as we stayed in Greely a few weeks ago. The staff was very friendly and we experience no wait-time even... though other restaurants in the area seemed very busy. I ordered the Salad and my partner ordered a pizza. Ordered the apricotblonde beer which was really nice while my partner also ordered a Not your father's root beer which he really enjoyed. For achain-restaurant it is good and the service was quite fast. The chicken was very obviously full of saline water to make it morejuicy which was not so nice. The dressing was standard and the salad a bit on the bland side. The staff and the service wereceived really give it and extra star along with the good beer selection. Read more
We ordered curbside pickup tonight only yo find out, this location doesn't offer it. The food looks overdone and was barely warm... when picked up. Not very happy as now we need to figure out something else for dinner. You need to do better and don't give theoption if your not going to offer it. We pay a good amount to feed our family amd have other options. We used to love your food,however, it seems like the quality isn't a priority anymore. Read more
Excellent service, we went around 6pm on a Saturday and did not have to wait long to be seated. Prompt service and did not wait... long to have water and drinks served. The wait for our food was not longer than average once we ordered and our food came outcooked properly and tasted excellent. Our server did a good job of checking on us to see if we needed anything and how the foodtasted. Excellent job! Read more
They was great. Very fresh and I love the waiters and waitress They always are bubbly and. Well y’all got my favorite pizza... see y’all next time Read more
We ordered the Italian Nachos, jalapeno bites, and pepperoni rolls from Grubhub. Our driver was on time and was fine. Our food... was a joke! The nacho chips were burnt, there was hardly any cheese and no peppers or pepperoni at all. When we were eating whatwe could, we found a bunch of red thread on a chip. The jalepeno pretzel bites didnt have enough jalepeno to taste and thecheese was watered down. The only decent thing we got was the pepperoni rolls. But by the time we found the red thread we wereso grossed out and couldnt eat it. Read more
This was our first time ordering through Google take out for Old Chicago. The process felt very easy and quick. There was also a... way to track where it was in the fulfillment process. I liked that part. Then, we got there to curbside pick up and waitedalmost 20 minutes. Big bummer. My favorite item is the salad because it has almonds but there were very few in mine. We alsotried the Cauliflower pizza which was good. Pretzel bites and pepperoni pizza. The food was okay but was cold by the time wegot home. We will not be partaking in the Google online order again for Old Chicago. Read more
Compared to Brighton, this place is awesome and not a funeral parlor. Taylor and Haley are always awesome and attentive in the... bar, even though I'm not a regular. More like a once a month guest. My Chicken Carbonara did not have and garlic in it, unlikeBrighton???? Read more