Reviews for Orange County Bagel in Goshen, NY
The worst bagel I?ve eaten. It?s like regular bread in the shape of a bagel. Maybe I came a bad day. I didn?t try anything. The... coffee was fine but the bagel, again, not good very bad. ???? Read more
Stopped here on my way to work. These bagels are not bagels. They look like bagels but they're bread bagels. Bagels are not... supposed to look and taste like a loaf of bread. I found it weird eating the bagel and could not finish it. It just didn't tasteright. Might as well get a Portuguese roll and put cream cheese on it. I mean the bagel was fluffy and it looked great but itsjust not a bagel! If you want to know what a real bagel tastes like, go to NYC or NJ. This isn't it! Sorry guys! I guess thereviews are high because people in this town don't really know what bagels are supposed to taste like. Btw, I got the bagelscooped out but that still doesn't matter. The consistency is not right regardless. A little overpriced i think but not by muchthe way the economy is right now. A bagel with scallion and a medium coffee came out to $6 and change. Read more
Second time in, and it?s confirmed? I?m a customer for life! Can?t go wrong, their bagels, sandwiches, heck we even had a great... salad back at the hotel we took back! Friendly down to earth staff, refreshing, and I used to work at a bagel shop. Brueggersstep your game up, this is the best shop I?ve been to! We love you Orange County Bagels Read more
Terrible experience. Staff was dry and not friendly. Asked for available cream cheese and the lady pointed to a sign. Then I... ordered three bagels toasted with cream cheese. One of the flavors wasn?t available after all? which is why I asked in the firstplace. After about 10 minutes of waiting I got my three bagels and went home. Upon getting home I pull the bagels out and theyare not toasted. Read more
I just had lunch here and I do have lunch here from time to time. I love their Asiago bagel for my sandwiches. The food has... always been delicious. I really like that they also give you a small side with your sandwich. I had the macaroni salad with mylunch today and it was tasty. I would definitely recommend trying this place out for yourself. You will not be disappointed. Read more
Love it here, super friendly locals, always feel at home and welcome. They make it a point to know their customers and take... care. Asiago bagel with scrambled egg, cheese, and crispy bacon is the best. Read more
BYOI: Bring your own ice! When it comes to their pastries, looks can be deceiving. You?re gonna need a wipe to get all the... stickiness off the bottles of juices. Also, do not expect the sandwiches to be hot!! Warm, welcoming service...no where to befound here. I?ve been here many times over the past handful of years and it has always been so good. This last visit was verydisappointing and shocking but not pleasantly. When I walked in, the first thing to catch my eye was all the yummy lookingpastries, cookies, muffins, etc. Key word=?looking?...more details on that later. The woman who took our order gave us mediocreservice. She did not greet us. She had no idea what the pastries were called. She took our order and that was it. We ordered 2salami, eggs and cheese on bagels with a cheese danish and apple turnover. While we waited for our breakfast sandwiches, we wentto get a juice from the cooler. The first juice bottle I picked up was pretty sticky. I went to grab a different one but thisone was even more sticky. So was the next one I picked up. They all were sticky. You know it?s bad when you have to pick theleast sticky bottle of juice. We found a clean table and sat down. One of the workers yelled across the restaurant to tell usour food was ready. We got up and I asked the guy behind the counter if he could fill up cups with ice. He rolled his eyes andwalked away. Then came back with two plastic cups with barely any ice, less than half way filled. When I asked if he could putsome more ice in the cups he swore that was all the ice he had. We went back to our table and started to eat. Our sandwicheswere not hot at all. The cheese was not melted and the meat was not heated thoroughly. This was the biggest disappointmentbecause their breakfast sandwiches have always been my favorite in the area. After our sad sandwiches, we were looking forwardto those ?good looking? pastries. We split them into pieces to share then tried the cheese danish first. The Read more
I have been living in Goshen for 4yrs now and every weekend this place is packed with people waiting on a long line, even people... like me who order ahead of time still are waiting a ridiculous time. You think these incompetent people would get another cashregister going so people dont have to wait 45 min to eat breakfast. Never going here AGAIN for their lack of common sense, whichin turn puts you in an aggravated mood and ruins your day! Read more