Reviews for Paesello's Pizzeria in Goshen, IN
Small place, take-out only, but very friendly staff and their pizza is our favorite in the county! They also have tasty subs,... sandwiches , salads, pastas, and breadsticks! Don't forget the home fries ( sliced thin like chips!) Enjoy! Read more
One of my favorite pizzas when I?m in the Goshen area! My wife enjoys the pasta.
Can?t get enough of the chicken Alfredo pizza. They?re so delicious and the medium is enough for 4 people at least. They do take... about 40 minutes so plan ahead! Read more
Very impressed! My husband is very picky with his pizza. He loved the sauce, crust and the amount of toppings Paesello?s puts in... their pies. This his favorite pizza place in town. In addition to that, I love that they have gluten free personal pizzas forfolks like me. Definitely coming back. Read more
We ordered a deluxe pizza for carry out. It was excellent, the crust was perfectly baked and tasty. The toppings were high... quality and the cheese was amazing. Highly recommend! Read more
Very friendly and very delicious! Our favorite pizza has always been a place up in Holton, Michigan but after I just had... Paesello's pizza.... well, this is by far our new favorite place. Delicious, fresh ingredients. I highly recommend! Read more
Finally ordered from here after 20 years. Ordered 2 pasta dinners. If your not a heavy eater one dinner can easily feed two.... The round bread included was delicious the best I have ever had for take out. The side salad was large for a side and well madewith notch above dressings. The meatballs are very good and obviously house made. I liked the baked mostaccioli but my wifewasnt a gan of the hard boiled egg pieces in it along with the thin sliced ham and pepperoni. I thought it gave more protein toa carb laden dish. The place is small but very clean and neat. Will order again when its pizza night. Read more
Order by phone and pickup at an outside window. Thick crust style. Excellent pizza.