Reviews for Gerace's Pizzeria in Goshen, IN

Pizza is not the same as it used to be. Very thin. We were pretty disappointed. To make matters worse, found a piece of black... hair baked into the pizza. Read more

Horrible, expensive pizza!! My wife and I both feel sick!! I'll never go back!! They can say all they want but our pizza was... disgusting and I'd never waste my money trying it again!! Read more

Never and I mean ever get the sandwiches! 45 minutes late the au juice was straight soy sauce . Save your money this place is... worse than any place in goshen . Bye bye $50 In the trash . Use to be great never again Jesus's Christ sell it before your shutdown . Disgusting. Read more

I used to love Gerace's, but I now had a bad experience after not coming here after a long time. I ordered a pasta Alfredo and... it smelled horrible and it tasted old. It was $22 for the dinner plate with chicken. I don't think ill be buying food hereagain. Read more

Order the thin crust, didn?t get it. Very little toppings but a lot of cheese.

UPDATE: the owner contacted us promptly, listened to our concerns, and quickly offered a full refund. We will give it another... try. We have always loved Geraces?s pizza but things have really gone downhill with the new owners. Pizza ordered tonight wasburnt and inedible. Took it back but no manager or owner to deal with the situation. Will not be ordering again. . Read more

We ordered a bomb pizza, which is usually my fav from this place. But this time we were extremely disappointed. Our pizza barely... had any cheese on it and there was no basil at all. Read more

Fantastic meat lovers pizza with a thick crust and loaded with toppings! Easy and efficient online ordering and reasonable... delivery time. Maybe a little pricey, but it was worth it! Read more