Reviews for Pauly's Pizza and Coney Shack in St Charles, MO

Pauly?s continues to deliver! What creative pizzas and options available on their menu. From being able to order by the slice to... all of the sides and specialty pizzas, Pauly?s never gets boring. Pair all of that with an exceptional staff and caring owner,you can?t go wrong with Pauly?s! ???????? Read more

The most delicious cauliflower crust pizza I've ever eaten is made here!!! Also the calzones are cooked to perfection, which is... amazing and more rare to find these days. Thank you so much - I'd give 10 stars if I could!! Read more

We absolutely loved our pizzas. They were cheesy, flavorful and cooked to absolute perfection. I'm looking forward to our next... visit. Read more

I have eaten here probably 6 different times and I have never had a bad experience. I have tried all the pizza crusts, various... toppings, calzones and the Connie dog. All tasted great but what is most impressive is the order is ready in 15-20 minutes fromcall in. This is the sweetest family. They all are so friendly and provide the best customer service. Read more

Tried the hand tossed and it wasn?t for me. Next day we tried a slice of the thin and was sold. Went home that night and... ordered an entire pizza. Will definitely return over and over again, wonderful addition to the neighborhood. Update to myoriginal review: I?m not sure what I just ate, but for the love of god it was awesome. This is the Boom Boom chicken pizza(grilled chicken, banana peppers, onion, bacon and pineapple). I?ll start by saying I despise pineapple on pizza, or so Ithought. The grilled chicken was extremely fresh and far from dried out. Copious amounts of bacon did not disappoint, and therest all tied together. The pineapple added some sweetness that balanced out the boom boom sauce heat to perfection. It wasthin crust with about 83lbs of cheese, give or take, and very crispy under all those toppings. I?d put this up against any pizzaout there, and eat it over and over. All I can say is make the time to try this delicious concoction!! ? at Pauly?s Pizza &Coney Shack. Read more

Great pizza, great people, great location. The owner was extremely cool and the ?za really hit the spot. The cheese and the... crust were awesome but here?s my one little criticism for Pauly and the gang. Switch to a made-from-scratch sauce using cannedSan Marzano tomatoes. The current sauce has a very slight ?frozen pizza? quality to it which leaves my score at around a7.9-8.1. If the little, extra, step of made-from-scratch sauce was taken I believe it would catapult the overall quality to theskies. In my opinion the sauce is the soul of the pizza and it?s what makes it stand out from others. Will it be more expensive?Yes. Will it take more time? Yes. That being said I strongly believe that?s the final puzzle piece. That will separate you guysfrom everywhere else still using pre-made sauce. Anyway I love this place and I?ll for sure be back. Would recommend to anyonein the area. Read more

I was pleasantly surprised! Tired of mediocre pizza from the big guys. The ingredients of the pizza were fresh with generous... proportions and the overall appearance was something off a commercial. Will definitely be coming back. Highly recommend. *BBQChicken Pizza Review Read more

It?s fantastic and so needed for lunch here in New Town! The pizzas are a great variety and the Coney dog So Good!! Best crust... and BBQ chicken ever had today!! Love the chili on the Dog! They even give our dogs treats! Everyone support them during thiscold winter coming!! Your friends here in New Town St Charles, Mo Read more