Reviews for Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom in Gillette, WY
The sandwich tasted great. The bun fell apart but other then that it was good. I give it three stars cause of the staff. They... seemed to be more interested in gossiping instead of helping out. One of the servers came to the front and gave them some greatdirection and leadership. I don?t know her name but she is someone I would love on my team. The rest of the staff at the frontkept on telling people we have no idea how long your wait is going to be. Customers left out upset and this means they lostbusiness. Food was fantastic. Read more
My 5 coworkers and I came in for dinner after work one night and it was what I would consider to be a moderately busy night in... the restaurant. The serving staff may have been a little shorthanded, but it seemed like our server would walk by us about 7 or8 times before she would acknowledge us. We also had an incredibly long wait for our drinks (at least 15 minutes) before ourorder was taken. The server was incredibly friendly when she did tend to us, but getting her attention was far more difficultthan necessary in my opinion. That being said, the food was incredible. Everybody at the table absolutely loved their food andthere was plenty of food on each dish. The prices were very fair for the quality and amount of food served. If the serviceimproved, I would gladly give this restaurant 5 stars across the board Read more
Very friendly and professional staff, and the food was quick and good. It's exactly what you expect, with great service on top.
Sarah was our server and she did an awesome job. Great attention to details, made us feel welcome and accommodated our wants.... She said it was her third day. We never would have guessed she was truly great. I work as a trainer in my profession and wishsome of the people I train could catch on that fast. Congratulations on an excellent employee. Read more
For a large selection of drinks and menu items, this place was very good. The beer on tap was good along with the vast... selection. The Italian Nachos were excellent. The wait staff is very busy but took care of our table(s) extremely well. I wouldrecommend this place to anyone. Read more
Place was not to busy. Service was very good, the food was exceptional, would definitely come here again.
We just had to stop going here. Loved the atmosphere and how personable the owner was. However, no matter how many times we come... here, the food is always overcooked, poorly executed and they are always messing up the order. The final straw was when theymessed up our order three times in a row and we still had to pay for our food because we ate it lol When you've been sitting forover an hour with meal after meal messed up you just might do the same. We didn't leave since my children were eating theirfood. Also, when you substitute your meat for poorer quality and admit to it, that is also a huge red flag. We will most likelynot be returning. 3rd time is the charm as they say. Read more
Great food and customer service! Always enjoy coming here. Had my sons birthday party here and the server was amazing, sang to... them and they both got a free dessert of their choice. Read more