Reviews for Old Germantown in Germantown, WI
First time checking this place out and I'd highly recommend!!! Drinks and food were amazing! We will be back :) They have a QR... code for every table so it makes it easy to place drink/food orders. Read more
Absolutely delicious food, cozy and relaxing atmosphere, great and speedy customer service! Pizza is delicious, the sausages are... awesome! Get the Thai Curry sausage for sure! I love the small town barn feel of this location. Plenty of outdoor seating,family friendly! I will be a returning customer Read more
My husband and I made a reservation after hearing so many great things about old Germantown. We got our table immediately, got... our beers even faster and the appetizer was amazing. We were even talking about brining the whole family here to celebratesomeone?s retirement when, after 2 and a half hours of ordering our pizza it finally arrived. At first sight it looked good,even smelled good. I couldn?t get my piece off from the other so I tried cutting into it, revealing a very moist and soggycrust. My husband tried to get his slice and it also wasn?t easy to cut through the goop. We brought it to the attention of theyoung lady at the counter who refunded our money but also had a bit of an attitude about it. It was very disappointing gettingan uncooked pizza after waiting that long and we will not be bringing the whole family back. IN RESPONSE TO THE RESPONSE: Wewould have been happy to wait three hours for the pizza, the rest of service, like we mentioned was great. It was that the pizzawas soggy and inedible and that no one caught that before it came to the table or believed us when I brought it to yourattention. Hope all goes well with your business and that this was only just a fluke. Read more
This was a fun and different place for dinner. There were fewer people on the day we went due to weather so we were able to get... seated immediately without a reservation but I can see this place being really busy on a normal weekend. We ordered online fromthe table QR code which was convenient. The appetizers were all delicious and the sausages were a bit bland but good. I lookforward to trying their pizza next time! Read more
Visited for the first time yesterday, and I have to say - great find. I absolutely love that to get here, you first drive up a... long gravel driveway to the farm. I must come back when the weather is warmer as I would have loved to hang outside in theirgreat outdoor space. Great variety of food - definitely recommend ordering their sausage. We did the five sausage option and itis definitely a lot of food! We also got the Irish Boxty Potatoe Fritters and wow, these were delicious.They have a great listof beer on menu and also wine. So lots to choose from! We ended our visit with a delicious Bailey's cream cupcake. Highlyrecommend coming. Family friendly place and the service was incredible. We interacted with numerous staff and everyone wasfriendly - It truly has that "make yourself at home" feel. Read more
Cute family run pizza restaurant off the beaten path. Difficult to find if you haven't been there before. A red wagon at the... drive way entrance is the only marker you're in the right place, it otherwise looks like the long driveway of any number offarms you'll see on the way. Mushroom ricotta pizza and pretzel bites were great. The sourdough pizza crust is amazing, theperfect balance of buttery, crunchy and chewy. Nice atmosphere. Read more
Very cool venue with really good food and hospitality. Worth the detour as it's a bit off the beaten path. Homemade sausages had... great flavor and there were so many things on menu we wanted to try. The gentleman who was helping our table gave us a lot ofrecommendations for things to do in Green Bay, even though we were Niners fans :) Suggestion to make seating and orderingprocess more clear. Probably wasted a good 15 minutes at beginning waiting for QR code or menus to be brought to table andwasn't clear if we were supposed to go to counter to order or not. Read more
We had a fantastic experience @ Old Germantown. It was for my 60th birthday and was gifted a free bottle of sauce. Inside felt... inviting and cozy, all of the pizza?s were phenomenal. Our party of 8 enjoyed pretzel bites, Brie cheese dip, and 7 pizzas.Drinks and food came out fast for a Saturday evening, and all of the staff was extremely pleasant. A very enjoyable experience,and I will definitely be back again! Read more